OPINION: No China cheap shots please, Mrs Clinton

Jakarta (The Jakarta Post/ANN) ¿ Two months ago it was Central Asia. A month later it was Africa. Now she is on a whistle-stop tour of Southeast Asia and East Asia, preceded by a brief stopover in the Cook Islands for the Pacific Islands Forum summit.

With the zealousness of an absent lover wooing a neglected beau, US Secretary of State Hillary Clinton has been consistent in promulgating her president's much touted pivot toward Asia. However, as we in Asia fully understand, it is not the message. It's the tone it is delivered in.

In the months following Barack Obama's pivot announcement, no one can doubt that the US is back ¿ back in Asia, that is ¿ politically, militarily and economically. Yet rather than evincing fervour for Asia, the nation's "return" has been marked with a preoccupation with China. Clinton's messages have all had the same tone, whether explicit or implicit: Dissuading other countries of the rise of Beijing's influence.

Speaking in Mongolia, China's rising democratic neighbour, two months ago, Clinton said that governments "can't have economic liberalisation without political liberalisation eventually".

As if referring to China's slowing economy, Clinton said: "Clamping down on political expression or maintaining a tight grip on what people read, say or see can create an illusion of security. But illusions fade ¿ because people's yearnings for liberty don't."

In Senegal a month later, Clinton tried to tout the tagline that the US was committed to "a model of sustainable partnership that adds value, rather than extracts it".

The secretary conceded that US policies in the past "did not always line up with our principles. But today, we are building relationships that are not transactional or transitory".

With respect to Clinton's statement, many in Indonesia and throughout Asia will respond with a bemused "Oh, really?"

Indonesia supports the values that Clinton touts. But such a manner of delivery is too divisive for Asia. Furthermore, playing the ¿values¿ card is just too convenient for a nation whose actions have not spoken louder than its words.

One can only remain wary of Washington's own economic intentions and wherewithal when it comes to rediscovering Asia.

Clinton's big words in Ulan Bator may have been a political rallying call, but her presence served as an even more potent lobbying effort for America's Peabody Energy as it competes with a Chinese state-owned enterprise for contracts for a huge coal deposit in the south Gobi, just 140 kilometres from the Chinese border.

Clinton's tour of Africa was a belated effort to wrest back influence lost in the continent as China grew to overshadow the US as its largest trading partner. Beijing's impact is such that the African Union headquarters in Addis Ababa was built as a gift from China, which has further extended its credit line to Africa to US$20 billion.

Facing a senior Chinese delegation in Cook Island, Clinton toned down her rhetoric, especially since she will also be in Beijing this week. Yet her efforts to suspend the extension of China's 'string of pearls' to Pacific islands seem paltry in comparison.

According to the Lowy Institute, Beijing has pledged over $600 million in loans to nations in the South Pacific since 2005.

In comparison Clinton ¿ the first US secretary of state to attend the annual South Pacific summit ¿ pledged last week $32 million in new projects, some 18 years after Washington suspended aid programmes to the South Pacific.

Indonesia, and most of Southeast Asia, will welcome the US pivot in Asia if it means a supportive peace presence in the region. What will be rejected is the seeming habit of major powers ¿ be they China or the US ¿ to define countries as allies or adversaries. And both Beijing and Washington have been guilty riling divisions.

The biggest threats to Asean's centrality are the gnawing moves that ultimately pit its 10 members against each other.

Southeast Asia has dealt with the powerful Middle Kingdom since the pre-Majapahit era, and it has always founds a way to persevere without submission. The last thing the region needs is acerbic commentary in Indonesia's backyard that will encourage retaliatory responses from Beijing.

If the purpose of Clinton's visits to Asian capitals is to parade on the high horse of rhetoric, she should attend the convention her Democratic Party in Charlotte, North Carolina, and not visit Jakarta.

Nations in the region ¿ and Clinton herself ¿ should heed her own words in Cook Islands: "I think, after all, the Pacific is big enough for all of us".

Loading...

Editor’s note:Yahoo! Philippines encourages responsible comments that add dimension to the discussion. No bashing or hate speech, please. You can express your opinion without slamming others or making derogatory remarks.

Odd Stories

  • Prosecutor in Berlusconi sex trial receives mail with bullets

    Prosecutor in Berlusconi sex trial receives mail with bullets

    Reuters - 10 hours ago
    Prosecutor in Berlusconi sex trial receives mail with bullets

    MILAN (Reuters) - The prosecutor in former prime minister Silvio Berlusconi's sex trial has received a series of anonymous letters of threats, including one with two bullets, Milan's chief prosecutor said on Thursday. The letters against Ilda Boccassini have become more frequent since she requested a six-year jail sentence and a lifetime ban on holding public office for Berlusconi, Edmondo Bruti Liberati said. ...

  • College student snares record long Burmese python near Miami

    College student snares record long Burmese python near Miami

    Reuters - Wed, May 22, 2013
    College student snares record long Burmese python near Miami

    By Barbara Liston ORLANDO, Florida (Reuters) - An 18-foot, 8-inch Burmese python set a record for the longest snake ever captured in South Florida, where the exotic species has taken up residence. College student Jason Leon snared the female python in a rural area southeast of Miami earlier this month, when he saw part of it sticking out from brush along the roadside, said Carli Segelson, a spokeswoman for the state's Fish and Wildlife Commission. ...

  • A gnome grows in Chelsea - at the flower show, that is

    A gnome grows in Chelsea - at the flower show, that is

    Reuters - Tue, May 21, 2013
    A gnome grows in Chelsea - at the flower show, that is

    By Paul Casciato LONDON (Reuters) - Some spectators at London's Chelsea Flower Show wouldn't be caught dead with one in the trunk of their Bentley, but garden gnomes have turned up at the show's 100th edition this year, for charity. The Royal Horticultural Society (RHS), which runs Chelsea in the grounds of the Christopher Wren-built Royal Hospital Chelsea, has lifted a ban on the ceramic figures with floppy hats and beards in order to raise funds for an RHS charity that supports the use of

  • Marijuana waste helps turn pot-eating pigs into tasty pork roast

    Marijuana waste helps turn pot-eating pigs into tasty pork roast

    Reuters - Tue, May 21, 2013
    Marijuana waste helps turn pot-eating pigs into tasty pork roast

    By Jonathan Kaminsky OLYMPIA, Washington (Reuters) - With Washington state about to embark on a first-of-its-kind legal market for recreational marijuana, the budding ranks of new cannabis growers face a quandary over what to do with the excess stems, roots and leaves from their plants. Susannah Gross, who owns a five-acre farm north of Seattle, is part of a group experimenting with a solution that seems to make the most of marijuana's appetite-enhancing properties - turning weed waste into pig

  • Jon Stewart's humor a hit with millions of envious Chinese

    Jon Stewart's humor a hit with millions of envious Chinese

    Reuters - Mon, May 20, 2013
    Jon Stewart's humor a hit with millions of envious Chinese

    By Jane Lee SHANGHAI (Reuters) - Humor may not always translate well, but Jon Stewart is picking up millions of fans in China, where his gloves-off political satire is refreshing for many in a country where such criticism is a rarity - especially when directed at their own leaders. A recent segment on North Korea scored over 4 million views on microblogger Sina Weibo, and even stodgy state broadcaster CCTV has used Stewart's "The Daily Show" in a report, though they wouldn't let a Chinese

  • The joy of chamber music according to Albert Tiu VERA Files - The Inbox

    By Pablo A. Tariman, VERA Files Chamber music enthusiasts will have another special treat when Singapore-based Filipino pianist Albert Tiu teams up with Belgian clarinetist  Marcel Luxen Saturday, June 1 at the Ayala Museum courtesy of the MCO Foundation. A … Continue reading →

  • Time matters little to world’s fastest jigsaw puzzle maker VERA Files - The Inbox

    By Maria Feona Imperial, VERA Files Perhaps for breaking a world record, she has already found the answer to every jigsaw puzzle ever made. But Georgina Gil-Lacuna has one more left unresolved: the puzzle of time. And she likes it … Continue reading →

  • Chinese, Taiwanese nationals with computer gadgets held VERA Files - The Inbox

    By LEILANIE ADRIANO, VERA Files LAOAG CITY, Ilocos Norte– At least 40 Chinese and 12 Taiwanese nationals who were found with several electronic and computer gadgets and accessories in a resort in Vigan were rounded up and detained for questioning, … Continue reading →

  • Ramos urges neutral probe of Taiwan incident, reminds Pinoys of Contemplacion case VERA Files - The Inbox

    By Ellen Tordesillas, VERA Files MAKASSAR, Indonesia—Former President Fidel V. Ramos has recommended the creation of a neutral investigation on the May 9 encounter between a Philippine patrol ship and Taiwanese fishing vessel in the disputed maritime boundary that resulted … Continue reading →

  • FVR leads call for reduction of budget for lethal weapons VERA Files - The Inbox

    By Ellen Tordesillas, VERA Files MAKASSAR, Indonesia—Former President Fidel V. Ramos Monday called on rich countries to reduce their budget for deadly weapons and realign resources for public safety, including navigation in the disputed waters in the South China Sea. … Continue reading →

POLL
Loading...
Poll Choice Options