Analysis: Aging hardware

Miami, Florida, United States (Reuters) - The seizure in Panama of a North Korean cargo ship carrying aging Cuban military hardware in need of repair is more a sign of hard times in Havana than of any sinister military threat, analysts say.

Although Cuba may have violated United Nations sanctions barring military trade with North Korea, the infraction could result in little more than a slap on the wrist as the Soviet-era weaponry appears unrelated to international concern over proliferation of nuclear weapons by Pyongyang.

"Based on what we know, the military impact seems to be negligible," said Philip Peters, a Cuba expert at the Virginia-based Cuban Research Center. "This material has nothing to do with the international community's core concern about North Korea, which is nuclear weapons and ballistic missiles."

The shipment included two anti-aircraft missile batteries, nine disassembled missiles, two MiG-21 aircraft, and 15 MiG engines, all Soviet-era military weaponry built in the middle of the last century.

The Cuban military was "using weapons and equipment of staggeringly old vintage" and the Pentagon had long since written off the island as a military threat, said Hal Klepak, professor of History and Strategy at the Royal Military College of Canada and author of a book on the Cuban military.

At the same time, Cuba's military doctrine was designed to deter any attack, and its defensive capacity was badly in need of an upgrade, he said.

"Nothing Cuba has, as the Pentagon has repeatedly made clear in its own analyses, constitutes a threat to the US or other neighbors, but if Cuba cannot keep any limited air-defense capability in being at all, then it cannot convince anyone that its conquest would not be easy to achieve," he said.

In a 1998 report, the Pentagon concluded that the collapse of the Soviet bloc in 1991 had seriously eroded the size and power of Cuba's military, which was left posing "a negligible threat to the US or surrounding countries."

The report said Cuba's army could no longer mount "effective operations" due to mothballed equipment, and it's air force had fewer than two dozen operation MiGs.

Despite the possible violation of UN sanctions, the Obama administration has reacted cautiously to the Panama seizure.

It went ahead on Wednesday with scheduled migration talks with Cuba, and rather than lash out at Havana, US officials have taken a wait-and-see approach, saying they plan to speak to the Cubans about the incident once all the facts are known.

Cuba says the "obsolete" weapons were being sent back to North Korea for repair and has insisted it remains committed to international law and nuclear disarmament.

Klepak termed the MiG-21, which first flew in the 1950s, "hopelessly out of date," as were the anti-aircraft radar systems reportedly on the ship.

"Cuba cannot afford to buy anything newer and does not have repair facilities of its own for such needs. Thus if it is not to scrap, for example, the aircraft entirely, it must repair and potentially update them in some areas," he said.

Cuba's dire financial situation most likely led it to turn to North Korea, allowing Havana to enter a barter arrangement, perhaps for sugar, Klepak added, noting that the North Koreans had repaired similar weaponry in the past in exchange for food.

While Russia and China could repair the systems, or perhaps modernize them, they would only do so for cash, he said.

The surreptitious nature of the cargo, and the ship's route with its transponder switched off when it left the Panama Canal to collect the Cuban weapons, indicated that Cuba knew it was violating the UN sanctions, but was willing to take the risk of being caught, according to some analysts.

Despite official US caution so far, the weapons shipment could hurt Havana's efforts to rekindle relations with Washington, given that Cuban-American members of Congress have already called for tougher action from the Obama administration.

Loading...

Editor’s note:Yahoo Philippines encourages responsible comments that add dimension to the discussion. No bashing or hate speech, please. You can express your opinion without slamming others or making derogatory remarks.

  • Philippine leader likens China to Nazi Germany
    Philippine leader likens China to Nazi Germany

    Philippine President Benigno Aquino drew a parallel Wednesday between present day China and Nazi Germany during a speech in Japan, hinting the world cannot continue to appease Beijing as it claims ever-more territory in the South China Sea. The comments come as disquiet grows over the quickening pace of China's land reclamation programme in international waters, including its construction of a runway long enough for large military planes. "If there was a vacuum, if the United States, which is …

  • Japan, Philippines huddle amid increasing China concerns
    Japan, Philippines huddle amid increasing China concerns

    TOKYO (AP) — The Philippine president is on his sixth visit to Japan in less than five years, signaling his country's deepening ties with Tokyo amid increasing concerns by both sides about China's assertiveness in regional seas. …

  • Buying a car? top 15 safety features to look for
    Buying a car? top 15 safety features to look for

    If not all, most of us understand the importance of Safety. That’s why most often we hear the reminder, “Safety First” from our family, friends and colleagues. But the question is, when it comes to buying a car, do we really put Safety first? According to the 2014 Initial Quality Studies by J.D. Power, a […] The post Buying a car? top 15 safety features to look for appeared first on Carmudi Philippines. …

  • Pagasa expects stronger cyclones to hit Phl this year
    Pagasa expects stronger cyclones to hit Phl this year

    The Philippine Atmospheric, Geophysical and Astronomical Services Administration (PAGASA) recently warned Filipinos to brace for stronger cyclones this year due to the El Niño phenomenon. “In terms of (the El Niño’s effect on tropical cyclones), we expect that more cyclones will reach the typhoon category, which is 118 kilometers per hour,” Flaviana Hilario, PAGASA deputy administrator for research and development, said. Hilario said the abnormal warming of the sea during an El Niño may …

  • US warns China vs ‘throwing elbows’
    US warns China vs ‘throwing elbows’

    Obama, in a discussion at the White House with a group of young leaders from Southeast Asian nations, said land reclamation projects in the South China Sea and West Philippine Sea were unproductive and called for an end to aggressive actions by all parties concerned. “China is going to be successful. In Vietnam, US Defense Secretary Ashton Carter said the US is not looking to militarize or escalate the situation in the South China Sea and West Philippine Sea where China and five other …

  • Phl, Japan to discuss military equipment transfer
    Phl, Japan to discuss military equipment transfer

    Japan and the Philippines will likely agree on the start of talks to sign an accord over the transfer of defense equipment, as both countries seek to strengthen cooperation amid the rise of an assertive China, Japanese government sources said Sunday. The agreement may be finalized when Prime Minister Shinzo Abe and President Aquino meet in Tokyo tomorrow as arrangements are also made for both leaders to express concern over China’s attempts to change the status quo at sea, the sources added. …

  • PNR test run set next week
    PNR test run set next week

    The Philippine National Railways (PNR) will conduct test run next week to ensure the safety of the train service prior to the resumption of its operations on June 15, an official said yesterday. PNR spokesman Paul de Quiros said test runs were set on June 9 and 10. PNR operations were suspended last month following the derailment of a southbound train near Nichols station in Makati City, which injured close to 50 passengers. …

  • CPP-NPA leader nabbed in Cavite
    CPP-NPA leader nabbed in Cavite

    Government security forces arrested an alleged second highest leader of the Communist Party of the Philippines-New People’s Army (CPP-NPA) and two others in Bacoor, Cavite Monday night. Adelberto Silva was arrested by military and police operatives at his home in Barangay Molino 5 at past 11 p.m., Army spokesman Lt. Col. Noel Detoyato said. Aside from Silva, arrested were his common-law wife Sharon Ronquillo and Isidro de Lima, who were also said to be members of the communist movement. …

POLL

Should Aquino be held accountable over the Mamasapano operations?

Loading...
Poll Choice Options