Apple loses bid for US ban on Samsung smartphones

A judge late Monday denied Apple's request to ban a set of Samsung smartphones from the US market after a jury found the South Korean electronics titan guilty of patent infringement.

Even though Apple was victorious in the patent case, the iPhone and iPad maker failed to prove that the technology at issue was the driving factor in people's buying decisions, US District Court Judge Lucy Koh said in her ruling.

"Though the phones do contain infringing features, they contain a far greater number of non-infringing features to which consumers would no longer have access if this court were to issue an injunction," Koh said.

"The public interest does not support removing phones from the market when the infringing components constitute such limited parts of complex, multi-featured products."

Koh said that it would not be in the public interest to deprive consumers of smartphones for "non-core features" covered by the patents involved.

"Weighing all of the factors, the court concludes that the principles of equity do not support the issuance of an injunction here," Koh wrote.

"First and most importantly, Apple has not been able to link the harms it has suffered to Samsung's infringement of any of Apple's six utility and design patents that the jury found infringed by Samsung products in this case."

The injunction sought by Apple was "extremely broad," covering 26 Samsung products as well as devices the company might launch in the future incorporating features protected by the patents, the judge noted.

Samsung -- the world's top mobile and smartphone maker -- was ordered by a US jury in August to pay Apple $1.05 billion in damages for illegally copying iPhone and iPad features for its flagship Galaxy S smartphones.

It has appealed the ruling.

Since then, two separate rulings by courts in Japan and the Netherlands have dismissed Apple's claims of patent infringement.

Loading...

Editor’s note:Yahoo Philippines encourages responsible comments that add dimension to the discussion. No bashing or hate speech, please. You can express your opinion without slamming others or making derogatory remarks.

  • Pagasa expects stronger cyclones to hit Phl this year
    Pagasa expects stronger cyclones to hit Phl this year

    The Philippine Atmospheric, Geophysical and Astronomical Services Administration (PAGASA) recently warned Filipinos to brace for stronger cyclones this year due to the El Niño phenomenon. “In terms of (the El Niño’s effect on tropical cyclones), we expect that more cyclones will reach the typhoon category, which is 118 kilometers per hour,” Flaviana Hilario, PAGASA deputy administrator for research and development, said. Hilario said the abnormal warming of the sea during an El Niño may …

  • US warns China vs ‘throwing elbows’
    US warns China vs ‘throwing elbows’

    Obama, in a discussion at the White House with a group of young leaders from Southeast Asian nations, said land reclamation projects in the South China Sea and West Philippine Sea were unproductive and called for an end to aggressive actions by all parties concerned. “China is going to be successful. In Vietnam, US Defense Secretary Ashton Carter said the US is not looking to militarize or escalate the situation in the South China Sea and West Philippine Sea where China and five other …

  • Phl, Japan to discuss military equipment transfer
    Phl, Japan to discuss military equipment transfer

    Japan and the Philippines will likely agree on the start of talks to sign an accord over the transfer of defense equipment, as both countries seek to strengthen cooperation amid the rise of an assertive China, Japanese government sources said Sunday. The agreement may be finalized when Prime Minister Shinzo Abe and President Aquino meet in Tokyo tomorrow as arrangements are also made for both leaders to express concern over China’s attempts to change the status quo at sea, the sources added. …

  • PNR test run set next week
    PNR test run set next week

    The Philippine National Railways (PNR) will conduct test run next week to ensure the safety of the train service prior to the resumption of its operations on June 15, an official said yesterday. PNR spokesman Paul de Quiros said test runs were set on June 9 and 10. PNR operations were suspended last month following the derailment of a southbound train near Nichols station in Makati City, which injured close to 50 passengers. …

  • CPP-NPA leader nabbed in Cavite
    CPP-NPA leader nabbed in Cavite

    Government security forces arrested an alleged second highest leader of the Communist Party of the Philippines-New People’s Army (CPP-NPA) and two others in Bacoor, Cavite Monday night. Adelberto Silva was arrested by military and police operatives at his home in Barangay Molino 5 at past 11 p.m., Army spokesman Lt. Col. Noel Detoyato said. Aside from Silva, arrested were his common-law wife Sharon Ronquillo and Isidro de Lima, who were also said to be members of the communist movement. …

  • Facebook launches artificial intelligence center in Paris

    Close to midnight in the Philippines, Facebook founder Mark Zuckerberg announced the opening of a research center in Paris, France, dedicated to artificial intelligence research. "One of our long term initiatives is to build a new generation of internet services that are more intuitive and can more easily connect you with the things you care about by understanding the meaning of voice, text, images, videos and other information," Zuckerberg said in his status update. "Our new Paris team will …

  • Fallout 4 countdown timer officially begins

    The long wait for Fallout fans may be finally over, as the official Bethesda website has set up a timer that is already ticking down to what may be the BIG ANNOUNCEMENT players have long been waiting for: Fallout 4. The countdown timer was unveiled at precisely 9 p.m. Philippine Time. Click here to visit the Fallout 4 official website and countdown timer. …

  • Taiwan, Philippines coastguards in brief stand-off despite work on pact

    TAIPEI/MANILA (Reuters) - Coastguard ships from Taiwan and the Philippines confronted each other in rich fishing waters south of Taiwan last week, officials from the two sides said, in an incident that comes as they are working on a pact to resolve maritime disputes. In 2013, Taiwan recalled its envoy to the Philippines, froze work permit applications and ordered military exercises in waters between the two sides to press for an apology for the shooting death of a Taiwan fisherman in waters …

POLL

Should Aquino be held accountable over the Mamasapano operations?

Loading...
Poll Choice Options