When Would A Bank Loan Hurt Less Than A HDB Loan?

For the most part, bank loans are about as pleasant as a venereal disease. The only difference is that VD doesn’t pretend to be polite while repossessing your house. So why in the hell would I advocate bank loans? Well, finance isn’t straightforward. That’s why bankers and salesmen have tongues you can use as corkscrews. And truth is, there are situations when a bank loan would make more sense than a HDB loan. Learn to spot the moments:


HDB flats

Build it and loan it out at high interest? Ha ha, what a rip-off! Lucky no one thought of it yet.


Which is Better?

I covered HDB vs. Bank in another article. But I’m also going to make a frank statement here: When you ask which loan is objectively better, that’s like me asking a bull fighter “Hey hombre, which hurts worse, the left horn or the right?”

The only useful answer is “Depends where you’re standing at the time”.

Same thing. Depending on your financial situation, there are times when a HDB loan hurts worse than a bank loan. Such as…


1. When You Don’t Need Added Security 



The only security the owner of this car needs, for example, relates to length and not money.


HDB loans have a 2.6% interest rate, whereas bank rates are barely above 1%. Even if you pick the worst bank package, you’d still have lower interest than HDB offers. What justifies the difference?


A HDB loan offers greater peace of mind. They won’t take your flat away. But if your job is already stable, what are you paying for?

Drop the “you never know what will happen” mindset, because it doesn’t work. It makes sense to plan for the most probable, not the improbable. If I tried to sell you insurance for meteor strikes or cloned dinosaur rampage, would you  buy it?

Same thing. Why take out a higher loan, to guard against something that’s never likely to happen? That’s just as bad as over-insurance. The money you save on a cheaper bank loan could be invested in shares, structured deposits, or self-upgrading; the returns from these are a better form of security anyway.


2. When You Don’t Care to Refinance


Accounting notes

Is this customer service? Instead of numbers, can you maybe explain it with sock puppets?


Some people don’t like refinancing. Maybe they don’t like book-keeping, or maybe it’s too much effort to spend 15 minutes every three years to check loan packages.

Whatever. These people will love bank loans; and the banks will love them back.

A lock-in clause typically lasts two years, and imposes a 1.5% penalty for refinancing during that time. This is a problem for people who want flexibility. But if you don’t intend to refinance, a lock-in clause becomes as relevant as Felicia Chin’s opinion.

In fact, a bank’s lock-in might actually work to your benefit: Long lock-in periods are often sweetened by lower rates, whereas a HDB loan won’t give further concessions just for staying on. So if you’re the type to pick a loan and stay with it to the end, a bank loan with low interest and lock-in is the way to go.


3. You Have Cash in Hand


Woman with lots of money

Protip: Not ideal for a property agent's profile pic.


“What’s that? Pay with cash instead of using CPF? That’s just crazy.”

No, no it’s not. What’s crazy is taking a HDB loan just so you can use your CPF, then suffering high interest on a lifetime of repayments.

“But Ryan,” you say, ”taking $20,000+ out of my bank account feels like a vasectomy without anaesthesia”.

But faithful reader, taking a 30 year loan at 2.6% would be like getting kicked in the crotch after.

If you are capable of paying the rest of your house after financing (80% maximum from banks), there’s no need to molest your CPF account. It’s growing at 2.5%, and that’s a solid rate that beats most investment products. And what are you going to do with all that money in your account anyway?

With our current inflation, those savings have the shelf life of sushi in a wet sock. Better use it for something, and soon. If you’re not investing the money, choose a bank loan and use it for the house.


4. When You’re Not in A Rush



Fun Fact: Turtles are often associated with of investment bankers. They're thick, slow, and actually reptiles.


One benefit of HDB loans is a lack of early payment penalties. So if you’ve had a sudden windfall, you can rush to pay off the balance. This spares you from years of accumulating interest.

It also caters to that minority who’ve received advice like “Pay off your home loan as soon as you can”. Which on the scale of bad advice, is up there with “When a policeman pulls you over, insult his mother and accelerate”. More details in this article.

For the majority of us, the home loan process is like a coach bus to Genting. It’s long, the headlights don’t work, and we may not get there alive. Under those conditions, we’d rather not rush. And if you agree that fast repayment’s irrelevant, why should it matter that banks have pre-payment penalties?


5. When The Market Rates Are Good


Bank outlet

According to our property investors, the current SIBOR rate is "Aiyeeaiyeearrrgh, kill me now".


When SIBOR or SOR rates are low, I’d say bank loans beat HDB loans in every aspect. Yes, even security, for the simple fact that smaller repayments mean more money in the bank.

This fluctuates every month, so you need to check. And while it used to involve four hours of phone calls and a migraine, that time is past; today you can look up free sites (like SmartLoans.sg) to compare rates in minutes.

Image Credits:
All Your Picture Are Belong To Us, MoneyBlogNewz, Kevin Lawver, Aunt Owwee

Do you think a bank loan would serve you better? Comment and tell us why!

Get more Personal Finance tips and tricks on www.MoneySmart.sg

Click to Compare Singapore Home Loans, Car Insurance and Credit Cards on our other sites.

More From MoneySmart

Editor’s note:Yahoo Philippines encourages responsible comments that add dimension to the discussion. No bashing or hate speech, please. You can express your opinion without slamming others or making derogatory remarks.

  • Lupita Nyong'o's $150,000 Oscars dress stolen from hotel
    Lupita Nyong'o's $150,000 Oscars dress stolen from hotel

    The $150,000 pearl-studded, custom-made Calvin Klein dress worn by Oscar-winning actress Lupita Nyong'o at this year's Academy Awards has been stolen, police said on Thursday. The gown, embellished with 6,000 natural white pearls, was stolen from Nyong'o's room at the London Hotel in West Hollywood, during the day on Wednesday, a spokesman for the Los Angeles County Sheriff's Department in West Hollywood said. "Ms Nyong'o was not in the room at the time of the theft," Deputy John Mitchell …

  • South Korea decriminalises adultery, condom shares soar
    South Korea decriminalises adultery, condom shares soar

    South Korea's Constitutional Court on Thursday struck down a controversial adultery law which for more than 60 years had criminalised extra-marital sex and jailed violators for up to two years. The decision saw shares in the South Korean firm Unidus Corp., one of the world's largest condom manufacturers, soar by the daily limit of 15 percent on the local stock exchange. "Even if adultery should be condemned as immoral, state power should not intervene in individuals' private lives," said …

  • National Geographic 'Afghan girl' in Pakistan papers probe
    National Geographic 'Afghan girl' in Pakistan papers probe

    Pakistani officials are investigating after the famous green-eyed "Afghan girl" immortalised in a 1985 National Geographic magazine cover was found living in the country on fraudulent identity papers. The haunting image of the then 12-year-old Sharbat Gula, taken in a refugee camp by photographer Steve McCurry, became the most famous cover image in the magazine's history. Now Pakistani officials say that Gula applied for a Pakistani identity card in the northwestern city of Peshawar in April …

  • U.S. flies most advanced surveillance plane from Philippines

    By Manuel Mogato MANILA (Reuters) - The United States has begun flying its most advanced surveillance aircraft, the P-8A Poseidon, out of the Philippines for patrols over the South China Sea, the U.S. Navy said on Thursday, acknowledging the flights for the first time. The United States, the Philippines' oldest and closest ally, has promised to share "real time" information on what is happening in Philippine waters as China steps up its activities in the South China Sea. China claims most of …

  • US-led strikes on IS after group seizes 220 Christians
    US-led strikes on IS after group seizes 220 Christians

    The US-led coalition has carried out air strikes against the Islamic State group in northeastern Syria, where the jihadists have launched a new offensive and kidnapped 220 Assyrian Christians. The raids on Thursday struck areas around the town of Tal Tamr in Hasakeh province, the Syrian Observatory for Human Rights said, without giving information on possible casualties. The town remains under the control of Kurdish forces, but at least 10 surrounding villages have been seized by IS, along …

  • ‘Noy angered by previous SAF failures to get Marwan’
    ‘Noy angered by previous SAF failures to get Marwan’

    Supt. Raymund Train, who led the SAF team that killed Marwan in Mamasapano, Maguindanao on Jan. 25, recounted in a sworn statement the meeting he and senior SAF officers had with Aquino in Malacañang on Nov. 30. Train said among the senior officers who attended the meeting were then PNP chief Director General Alan Purisima, SAF chief Director Getulio Napeñas, SAF deputy commander Chief Supt. Noli Taliño and intelligence group chief Senior Supt. Fernando Mendez. …

  • Militants abduct more Christians, smash ancient artifacts
    Militants abduct more Christians, smash ancient artifacts

    BEIRUT (AP) — Islamic State militants seized more Christians from their homes in northeastern Syria in the past three days, bringing the total number abducted by the extremist group to over 220, activists said Thursday. …

  • IS executioner 'Jihadi John' named as London graduate
    IS executioner 'Jihadi John' named as London graduate

    "Jihadi John", the masked Islamic State group militant believed responsible for beheading of at least five Western hostages, has been named as Kuwaiti-born computing graduate Mohammed Emwazi from London. "Jihadi John", nicknamed after Beatle John Lennon due to his British accent, is believed to be responsible for the murders of US journalists James Foley and Steven Sotloff, British aid workers David Haines and Alan Henning and American aid worker Abdul-Rahman Kassig. …


Should Aquino be held accountable over the Mamasapano operations?

Poll Choice Options