The Best Time to Change Your Car in Singapore

If you’re like me, you only change cars once the traffic police stop you. Then the cop who pulls me over makes choking noises, while deciding to laugh or cry. Well, don’t you mock me! Cling-wrap is a perfectly good alternative to windscreens! Anyway, MoneySmart readers might wonder about the financial impact of changing cars. In this article, I look at how to time your upgrade (or downgrade, which is any time you’re buying a Proton):


Honda car on show

"And if you buy first, we'll give you this free guide to insider trading."


1. Now is Not the Best Time

I’ll start with a straight answer: Not now. Okay? That’s April 2012, which will go down in Singapore history as “That time when everyone who could afford a car was subject to CID investigation.”

With COE bids in excess of $90,000, there’s only one good reason to buy a car this month; and it involves a gang fight, 15 stab wounds, and being too far from A&E. Anything less is insufficient reason to even look at a new car. Because the COE adds tremendous cost to the vehicle (the certificate might cost more than the car), it’s important to track the COE rates.


Expensive cars on a Singapore road

"I have ways of affording my car. Oh, and here's my house…it's that dumpster around the corner."


COE rates are affected by the current car quotas. Since the government intends to lower that quota in August, we can expect the prices to keep on rising, at least till 2013.

No promises, but 2013 is when the 10 year COEs from 2005 begin to expire. Back then, the car quota was a lot higher, and they were handing out COEs like door prizes. As those COEs die out, there will be more room for cars on the road. Most car owners who got their COE in 2005 will also be eager to scrap in 2013, since they want their two year rebate.


2. Your Maintenance Costs are Too High

Maybe you’ve played live action Grand Theft Auto once too often. Or maybe the mechanic at the plant had one too many beers the night before. Whatever the case, some cars cost more to maintain than they’re worth.

Singaporeans hesitate to change cars just because of maintenance issues. After all, cars suffer rapid depreciation, and COE bidding is about as enjoyable as open heart surgery. The sale of the old car won’t cover the cost of the new one. But do the maths, and you might find keeping a lousy car costs you more.


Datsun engine

"Sure, I can fix it. But you'll have to pay the museum for the right parts."


Here’s an easy way to decide:

  1. Total the monthly cost of keeping your car (fuel, ERP, repayments, maintenance, etc.)
  2. Total the cost of your car maintenance over one year, then find the average monthly cost of maintenance.
  3. Compare the averaged monthly cost of maintenance to the monthly cost of keeping your car.


As a general rule, your vehicle is counter-productive if the maintenance cost equals or exceeds 20% of the total monthly cost.

If you’re self-employed, and rely on your car for income, you should also count the days when your vehicle is unavailable. Include your income for the day as part of the maintenance cost.


3. The Five Year Mark

Five is a magic number, because of the PARF rebate. Right up to year five, the PARF rebate remains at a steady 75%. Beyond that, every year reduces the rebate amount by another 5%. Likewise, note that cars depreciate most heavily within the first three years.

All this suggests that, if you want to change your car, don’t take your time. The longer you wait, the more expensive it will be. But of course, there are other factors involved. If COE prices are too high for your taste, for example, you may have no choice but to wait. In which case, you can aim for…


Antique car

"Yeah, that's a five year old car alright…back in 1895 it was."


4. The Eight Year Mark

You want to quickly get your COE rebate, before it expires. This rebate is based on the amount of “unused time” on your COE. So if you have your car scrapped at eight years, you get paid two years worth of your COE.

By coincidence, eight years is also when most cars start to wear down. Car manufacturers like to claim new vehicles last much longer than old ones, but I believe that as much as I do Ris Low’s condom advice. Car manufacturers make the vehicles last longer so the public will buy fewer cars? Yeah, sure.

Anyway, after eight years you’ll be driving something that would look better on The Flintstones. Cash in, grab the rebate, and change cars. There’s little benefit to waiting the full 10 years.


Car break down

"You want my 8 year old car? I'll trade it to you for cab fare."


5. You Have No Upcoming Loans

Look three months ahead. Are you going to need any kind of loan? If your housing loan is already approved, and you don’t see any other loans you’ll need, go ahead and change cars.

Otherwise, it’s inadvisable get a car loan just before another major loan (e.g. home loan). It might not prevent you getting another loan, but it might affect the amount you can borrow. Getting a new car could mean your bank will only finance 60 – 70% of your house, instead of the usual 80%.

While it’s not common, a bank might also refuse to give you a home loan until your car payment is settled.


Cup of coffee

"We decided to extend you a loan you can afford. You just spent it on that coffee."


Image Credits:
linademartinez, Shiny Things, asgw, Roberto Verzo, andrijbulba, Vasenka, netan

Are you looking to change cars? Comment and tell us your worries!

Get more Personal Finance tips and tricks on

Click to Compare Singapore Home Loans, Car Insurance and Credit Cards on our other sites.

More From MoneySmart

Editor’s note:Yahoo Philippines encourages responsible comments that add dimension to the discussion. No bashing or hate speech, please. You can express your opinion without slamming others or making derogatory remarks.

  • Que nails first title in 3 years

    The three-time Asian Tour champion, who bounced back from a mediocre start of 72 and 71 with a fiery 66 Friday to tie Tabuena at helm, pooled a 72-hole total of seven-under 281 to nail the elusive win on the ICTSI Philippine Golf Tour worth P650,000. Hounded by poor putting, Tabuena went birdie-less for the first time in a long while but still stayed in the title hunt with a slew of pars at the back until he bogeyed the 17th and fell by two. …

  • Church: Donate to ‘Alay Kapwa’

    An official of the Church’s social action arm has asked the faithful to be generous when making a donation to "Alay Kapwa" today, Palm Sunday, which is also designated as Alay Kapwa Sunday.   Fr. Edu Gariguez, executive secretary of the Catholic Bishops’ Conference of the Philippines-National Secretariat for Social Action (CBCP-NASSA), said the faithful should generously give to Alay Kapwa as the amount collected will be used as emergency funds for crisis and calamities both from natural and …

  • ‘PNP’s systematic anti-crime drive to be sustained

    Department of the Interior and Local Government (DILG) secretary Manuel ‘Mar’ Roxas II vowed to sustain the Philippine National Police’s (PNP) deliberate, programmatic and determined approach in fighting criminality.  “The President and Filipino people can be assured that the PNP will not slow down in its mission of fighting criminality, not only in Metro Manila but nationwide," said Roxas, who bared that there has been a significant drop in criminal activities within Metro Manila, especially …

  • Visayas grid to benefit from new Luzon power plants

    Owing to the existing transmission interconnection, Visayas grid is seen benefitting from the projected ‘oversupply’ that may saturate Luzon in the next three years. The Department of Energy and players from the power industry have noted the scant flow of capital for new power projects in Visayas, but they underscored that the transmission link-up would enable the sharing of energy between the two grids. First Gen executive vice president Ernesto B. Pantangco, who is also vice president of …

  • Arroyo’s co-accused permitted to undergo hospital procedure

    A co-accused of former President and now Pampanga Representative Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo in a plunder case has been allowed by the Sandiganbayan First Division to undergo a medical procedure tomorrow. The graft court permitted former Philippine Charity Sweepstakes Office (PCSO) board member Benigno Aguas, who was also its former budget and accounts manager, to undergo a cardiopulmonary/endocrine clearance procedure at the St. Luke's Medical Center in Quezon City this morning. Aguas, who is …

  • Petron expands petroleum retail operations

    Following the completion of its re-branding on acquired assets, leading Philippine oil firm Petron Corporation is now setting its goal on expanding its retail network in Malaysian petroleum market. The company has emphasized “20 more sites are in various stages of construction and commissioning.” On the downstream petroleum industry, it is the first time that a Filipino firm had brought its brand to an offshore market. It is technically some sort of ‘symbiosis’ when it comes to investments …

  • PAGASA: Storm may enter PH by Wednesday

    It may be a wet and windy Holy Week due to an erstwhile low pressure area which has intensified into a tropical storm with international name "Maysak,” according to the Japan Meteorological Agency.As of yesterday morning, the Philippine Atmospheric, Geophysical and Astronomical Services Administration (PAGASA) estimated the cyclone at about 3,300 kilometers east of Mindanao and outside the Philippine area of responsibility (PAR).Should it maintain its present speed and track, it may enter the …

  • News In Brief

    The weighted average rate stands at P44.796 MINDANAO INFRASTRUCTURE SHARE INCREASED In a bid to boost the Mindanao economy, the Philippine government has increased the southern island’s share of the 2015 infrastructure budget to 30%, or around $4 billion, said Public Works and Highways Secretary Rogelio Singson at the Philippines Investment Forum in Manila last week. “In 10 years’ time it’s still likely to be 30% because while the Philippines is committed to growing renewables, demand will …


Should Aquino be held accountable over the Mamasapano operations?

Poll Choice Options