Parallaxis

Post-RH politics

People celebrate after legislators pass a landmark birth control bill in Manila on December 17, 2012. Philippine Catholic church leaders vowed Tuesday to overturn a birth control bill after lawmakers ... more 
People celebrate after legislators pass a landmark birth control bill in Manila on December 17, 2012. Philippine Catholic church leaders vowed Tuesday to overturn a birth control bill after lawmakers passed legislation to make birth control more widely available less 
1 / 11
AFP News
Tue, Dec 18, 2012 4:40 PM PHT
A reconciled version of the Reproductive Health Bill (House Bill No. 4244 and Senate Bill No. 2378) has now been ratified by the two houses of Congress, only two days after it passed third reading. It is now certain to be signed into law having been certified as urgent by the popular president, Benigno “Noynoy” Aquino III.

The RH bill achieved a landmark of sorts, comparable to the passage of the Rizal Law in 1956. Like the latter, it passed despite a bitter, all-out, and massive campaign by the conservative Roman Catholic hierarchy. Its difference is that, while the Rizal Law touched the nationalist nerve of Filipinos, the RH bill rode on human rights and women power. The latter have come of age in the Philippines, mainstreaming into the national consciousness.

Backround: RH bill awaits PNoy's signature after Congress' ratification

In both cases, the conservative Catholic hierarchy tried a wide variety of tactics, from using expert testimonies to more faith-based arguments, from appealing to lawmakers to threats of negative campaigns against pro-RH legislators in the 2013 elections. After the passage of the bills, there were still pronouncements coming from some bishops for a disobedience campaign, a case in the Supreme Court, and a partisan political campaign for anti-RH candidates. Earlier, there had been isolated calls for excommunication of the president and pro-RH proponents and comparison of the president to the Connecticut school murderer.

The behavior of the conservative Catholic hierarchy borders—if not actually crosses over—the thin constitutional line separating the church and state. There is already the historical record of revolts and revolution against friars and the Church authority on temporal matters on which people disagreed with the latter. The popularity of the Church positions on social issues, including its eventual anti-Marcos dictatorship position, relies heavily on their being aligned with the best positions already embraced by its flock. In this case, the flock leads the shepherd.

Related story: Philippine president accused of 'bribing' Congress

In resorting to extremist behavior, there is the danger that the conservative Catholic hierarchy may be perceived of overdoing its opposition to the RH bill. For some of them, it seems, the RH bill has become the be-all and end-all of its relations to the Aquino administration, to the government itself, and even to all Filipino Catholics. The latter were told off to leave the Catholic fold.

Ironically, if this extremist behavior persists, it will only provoke the latter. When ordinary people, most of whom are Catholics, cannot identify with the Church anymore, many will leave to become converts to other religions, Christian or otherwise, or become non-practicing Catholics. It is a dangerous behavior with graver consequences for the Church than to the State.

Also read: Philippine birth control fight not over: bishops

Some bishops—and the Aquino administration and most others in the pro-RH group—had already called for leaving the dispute behind, cooperate on monitoring and implementation of the RH law, and go on to more productive relations and projects.

There is sense in their arguments. The RH bill—or the RH law—is already in the throes of birthing.
  • China angered by Britain's report on human rights, cancels talks
    China angered by Britain's report on human rights, cancels talks

    BEIJING/LONDON (Reuters) - China on Tuesday condemned Britain for interfering in its domestic affairs, in response to a human rights report, a day after the British government said Beijing had called off human rights talks. Britain listed China as "a country of concern" in its annual human rights report last week, saying it had observed increased curbs on freedom of expression, association and assembly in 2013. It also cited reports of "the forcible suppression of ethnic unrest in Tibet and …

  • Viagra Ice Cream Arouses Controversy
    Viagra Ice Cream Arouses Controversy

    The long list of unnatural food combinations just grew a little bigger: Viagra and Champagne ice cream. The treat — which has the familiar blue hue of the popular erectile dysfunction (ED) drug — is the brainchild of Welsh food inventor Charlie Harry Francis, who created the product for one of his "A-list celebrity clients." Since the drug (known as sildenafil citrate) was approved in 1998, Viagra has aroused the scrutiny of health care professionals and Food and Drug Administration …

  • Study: Samsung phone durable, but iPhone has edge
    Study: Samsung phone durable, but iPhone has edge

    NEW YORK (AP) — Samsung's new Galaxy S5 smartphone is more durable than last year's model and other leading Android phones, but the iPhone 5s outperformed all of them in part because of its smaller size, a new study finds. …

  • Miley Cyrus hospitalised
    Miley Cyrus hospitalised

    Miley Cyrus has cancelled another concert after being taken to emergency for severe allergic reactions. …

  • PH grants visa-free privilege to 7 more countries
    PH grants visa-free privilege to 7 more countries

    Travelers from seven more countries can now experience how fun it is in the Philippines without worry, as the government extended them visa-free privileges. …

Editor’s note:Yahoo Philippines encourages responsible comments that add dimension to the discussion. No bashing or hate speech, please. You can express your opinion without slamming others or making derogatory remarks.

  • China angered by Britain's report on human rights, cancels talks

    China angered by Britain's report on human rights, cancels talks

    Reuters - Tue, Apr 15, 2014
    China angered by Britain's report on human rights, cancels talks

    BEIJING/LONDON (Reuters) - China on Tuesday condemned Britain for interfering in its domestic affairs, in response to a human rights report, a day after the British government said Beijing had called off human rights talks. Britain listed China as "a country of concern" in its annual human rights report last week, saying it had observed increased curbs on freedom of expression, association and assembly in 2013. It also cited reports of "the forcible suppression of ethnic unrest in Tibet and …

  • Viagra Ice Cream Arouses Controversy

    Viagra Ice Cream Arouses Controversy

    LiveScience.com - Tue, Apr 15, 2014
    Viagra Ice Cream Arouses Controversy

    The long list of unnatural food combinations just grew a little bigger: Viagra and Champagne ice cream. The treat — which has the familiar blue hue of the popular erectile dysfunction (ED) drug — is the brainchild of Welsh food inventor Charlie Harry Francis, who created the product for one of his "A-list celebrity clients." Since the drug (known as sildenafil citrate) was approved in 1998, Viagra has aroused the scrutiny of health care professionals and Food and Drug Administration …

  • One dead as S. Korea ferry with 476 passengers sinks

    One dead as S. Korea ferry with 476 passengers sinks

    AFP News - Wed, Apr 16, 2014
    One dead as S. Korea ferry with 476 passengers sinks

    South Korea's coastguard said Wednesday one person had been killed as it struggled to rescue 476 people -- mostly high school students -- aboard a ferry that ran aground and sank off the southern coast. "The ferry is almost completely submerged," Lee said, adding that a detachment of South Korean Navy SEALS were taking part in the rescue. Of the 450 passengers on board the ferry bound for the southern resort island of Jeju, 325 were students from a high school in Ansan, south of Seoul. The …

POLL
Loading...
Poll Choice Options