The Inbox

Aquino’s fishing ban not-so-well thought out

By Ellen Tordesillas

It's good that former Marine Capt. Nick Faeldon didn't push through with his planned voyage Panatag shoal, also known as Scarborough shoal, where an almost one- and- half-month long standoff between the Philippines and China is a subject of informal diplomatic talks.

Faeldon, who was imprisoned for seven years for his participation in the 2003 Oakwood mutiny against Gloria Arroyo, had planned to set sail for Panatag shoal, last Friday together with fishermen from his home province, Batanes and fishermen from Masinloc, who are most affected by the conflict.

A call from the President Aquino Thursday aborted the plan, which would have really further riled the Chinese who are claiming the shoal, more than a thousand nautical miles away from their mainland. (Panatag shoal is 124 nautical miles from Zambales.)

Faeldon and his fishermen companions had planned to raise the flag in Panatag shoal to assert Philippine sovereignty on the disputed rocks.

Faeldon, who was a recipient of Aquino's amnesty proclamation for soldiers who rebelled against Gloria Arroyo, said he "trust(s) the wisdom of the government that it will be better for current efforts to resolve the standoff there."

Now that the provocation that the Faeldon Panatag shoal trip would have caused has been aborted, the President perhaps can pay attention to the plight of the Masinloc fishermen, who are reported to be adversely affected by the fishing ban that the President ordered on Panatag shoal Monday last week, apparently in retaliation to the fishing ban imposed by China on the area effective May 16 covering areas north of longitude 12 degrees in the South China Sea, Scarborough Shoal included.

Foreign Secretary Albert del Rosario said the Philippines does not recognize China's fishing ban "in as much as portions of the ban encompass our economic exclusive zone."

"But the President has decided that, in view of the accelerated depletion of our Marine Resources, it would be advisable for us to issue our own fishing ban for a period of time to replenish our fish stock," del Rosario said.

While China's fishing ban is well thought of strategy, that of the Philippines has created another set of problems for Filipino fishermen.

Retired Commodore Rex Robles said the Chinese fishermen, at this time of the year, usually stay away from Panatag shoal because the big waves and the rains that come with the Southwest monsoon. They are expected to be back sometime in October and November.

But even if the Chinese fishermen head home, the Chinese surveillance ships will remain in the vicinity of the Panatag shoal.

The Masinloc fishermen, on the other hand, have to continue fishing because that's their only means of livelihood and chances are, they would be sailing to areas near Panatag shoal. What if the Chinese surveillance ships apprehend them? The Philippine government would be in an awkward position because the fishermen also violated their own government's ban?

Robles also is asking if the President has thought of an alternative livelihood for the fishermen during the ban.

He said whenever there is a crisis in foreign countries and Overseas Filipino Workers are in danger, the government immediately releases a budget to bring them home. "I haven't heard of the government releasing a budget for the Masinloc fishermen whose work and income are also in jeopardy."

Robles is also asking if the Department of Social Welfare and Services has included the fishermen who will be affected by the fishing ban among the recipients in its Conditional Cash Transfer program.

Loading...

Editor’s note:Yahoo Philippines encourages responsible comments that add dimension to the discussion. No bashing or hate speech, please. You can express your opinion without slamming others or making derogatory remarks.

  • SE Asia Stocks-Mixed; Indonesia and Philippines end losing streak

    JAKARTA, May 4 (Reuters) - Southeast Asian stock markets traded mixed on Monday with stocks in Indonesia and Philippines rebounding after a recent bout of weakness. The Indonesian stock index closed up ... …

  • 2 coast guard men, village chief, abducted in Philippines

    MANILA, Philippines (AP) — Police say gunmen clad in military uniform have abducted two Philippine coast guard personnel and a village chief on a southern island then sped away in two motorboats. …

  • Filipino on US most wanted list killed: rebels, military
    Filipino on US most wanted list killed: rebels, military

    A Filipino on the United States' list of most wanted "terrorists" has been killed in a firefight in the southern Philippines, Muslim rebel leaders and the military said Monday. Abdul Basit Usman was killed in a remote mountainous area while being escorted by members of the Moro Islamic Liberation Front (MILF), the nation's biggest rebel group, its vice chairman Ghazali Jaafar said. Security forces had been hunting Usman since he escaped from a January police raid that killed Malaysian …

  • SE Asia Stocks-Mixed; Indonesia ends 7-day losing streak

    JAKARTA, May 4 (Reuters) - Southeast Asian shares mostly traded mixed on Monday, with Indonesia and the Philippines rebounding after a recent bout of weakness. Indonesian stock index rose 1.3 percent after ... …

  • Philippines says Islamist militant was killed by followers

    The Philippines' most wanted Islamist militant, whose death at the weekend could boost peace efforts in the country's south, was killed by his own bodyguards in pursuit of a bounty offered by the United States, the head of the military said on Monday. Abdul Basit Usman, a militant with strong al Qaeda links who was blamed for numerous bomb attacks in the southern Philippines, had been hunted by security forces since 2002. "There was in-fighting among his group," General Gregorio Pio Catapang …

  • EM ASIA FX-Firm dollar, weak China factory survey hurt Asia FX

    * Won falls on weak exports, PMI; mkt wary of intervention * Rupiah down on bonds, NDFs; Indonesia's Q1 GDP eyed * Philippine peso lowest in more than a month (Adds text, updates prices) By Jongwoo Cheon ... …

  • Philippine military chief confirms wanted militant killed

    MANILA, Philippines (AP) — The Philippine military chief confirmed Monday that wanted Filipino bomb-maker Abdul Basit Usman, who has links to the Indonesian-based Jemaah Islamiyah terrorist network and is a suspect in deadly bomb attacks in the south, has been killed. …

  • PSC sports venues deteriorating – COA
    PSC sports venues deteriorating – COA

    The Commission on Audit (COA) has noted the sorry state of the country’s sports venues despite supposedly receiving sufficient funds from the government. It reported that the Philippine Sports Commission (PSC) got an additional budget of P626.563 million in 2013 alone but failed to maintain and upgrade the Rizal Memorial Sports Complex (RMSC) in Malate, Manila and the Philsports Complex in Pasig City. This, according to the COA report, is already a disadvantage to the country’s athletes. …

POLL

Should Aquino be held accountable over the Mamasapano operations?

Loading...
Poll Choice Options