The Inbox

Genetically modified crops threaten organic agriculture

Greenpeace presscon

By Jonathan de Santos,VERA Files

The country's organic farmers could lose access to international agricultural markets if their crops are continually exposed to genetically-modified crops which are a source of pollen contamination.

This is what happened to corn farmers in Alfonso Lista town in Ifugao province when a contract for them to supply organic corn to Japan was canceled, said Daniel Ocampo, sustainable agriculture campaigner for Greenpeace Southeast Asia.  Buyers from Japan stopped importing the Ifugao corn when they found that crops had been contaminated by genetically-modified corn being grown in the same town.

Ocampo, speaking Wednesday at a Greenpeace press conference on the risks of allowing field testing of genetically-modified organism (GMO) crops, said the organic agricultural trade has "no tolerance for contamination."

Agriculture Secretary Proceso Alcala told reporters at the Ninth National Organic Agriculture Congress in Cebu City earlier this month that organic agriculture will allow Filipino farmers to compete with cheaper produce from the rest of the region. The Department of Agriculture has already set aside P950 million in the proposed 2013 national budget to promote organic farming.

Ocampo said, however, that "there is more to being organic than not using chemicals."

Germany-based International Federation of Organic Agriculture Movements (IFOAM), which has been promoting an international standard for organic agriculture and which helped organize First International Organic Marketing Conference in Manila in October, considers GMOs an "inappropriate technology."

The IFOAM Norms for Organic Production and Processing, which was released in August, prohibits "the deliberate use or negligent introduction of genetically engineered organisms or their derivatives" into an organic farm and requires farmers to protect their crops from contamination.

Tushar Chakraboty, principal scientist with the Gene Regulation Laboratory of the India Institute of Chemical Biology, said at the same press conference that that will be difficult with open field testing of GMO crops.

Citing a study that prompted the Supreme Court of India to order a 10-year moratorium on GMOs because they posed risks to health and the environment, Chakraboty said pollen from GMO crops could contaminate regular crops. A Greenpeace briefing paper on genetically-modified eggplant said field testing will "undoubtedly lead to contamination."

Greenpeace presscon2Farmers of traditional crops also face the risk of contamination, Ocampo said. Tests done on white corn, a traditional staple, in Sultan Kudarat province found evidence of contamination by genetically-modified corn that contain the Bacillus thuringenesis (Bt) bacterium. The corn from Sultan Kudarat goes to bigger markets like Cebu, he said, and consumers may be unaware they may be eating genetically-modified corn.

Chakraboty warned that once regular crops are contaminated, "how can you roll back the gene flow?"

The problems that contamination bring go beyond breaking into organic agriculture markets. Chakraboty said there have been no rigorous, long-term studies on whether the protein produced by genes from the Bacillus thuringenesis (Bt) bacterium and used as a pesticide, is safe for human consumption.

"No short- or long-term study has shown that they are safe for humans, livestock, or biodiversity. And all scientific studies about the benefits of GM crops are conducted by the same companies that sell it," he also said.

The University of Mindanao in North Cotabato, which has been field testing Bt eggplant, has said, however, that Greenpeace's fears have no basis either. In a press statement in May, the university said "there has been no incontrovertible proof that genetically modified crops caused any disease or ruined any traditional crops. Neither has there been any perilous consequence to man, nature, environment and land."

The Southeast Asian Regional Center for Graduate Study and Research in Agriculture in Los Baños, Laguna, has also said in an online primer on Bt eggplant that the Department of Agriculture monitors the field trials.

A briefing paper, also published by SEARCA, quotes Dr. Serge Francisco, project leader for Impact and Policy Research at the Philippine Rice Research Institute, as saying Bt eggplant offers "a 'win-win situation' for the environment and farmers as it has 'few (if any) unintended environmental effects,' better marketable yield and a lower production cost."

Despite that, Greenpeace has demanded that the government stop the field testing of GMOs and to cancel approval for 67 GMOs already being brought to the Philippines. "Instead, they should (be) supporting ecological solutions that ensure food security and sound environment as alternatives that will guarantee a healthy, viable and sustainable agriculture to feed the country," Greenpeace said in a statement.

The group said that aside from the threatening health and the environment, GMOs also lead to the increased use of pesticides and herbicides. Genetically-modified crops also threaten farmers by "locking them into an industrial agriculture system that enables the monopoly of a few giant agro-chemical companies who have control of the seeds," the group said.

Greenpeace filed petitions for a Writ of Kalikasan and a Writ of Continuing Mandamus before the Supreme Court in April to stop field trials of Bt eggplant. The Court issued a Writ of Kalikasan in May  while hearings on the petition for the Writ of Continuing Mandamus are ongoing.

(VERA Files is put out by senior journalists taking a deeper look at current issues. VERA is Latin for true.)

Loading...

Editor’s note:Yahoo Philippines encourages responsible comments that add dimension to the discussion. No bashing or hate speech, please. You can express your opinion without slamming others or making derogatory remarks.

  • Philippine's Aquino revives comparison between China and Nazi Germany
    Philippine's Aquino revives comparison between China and Nazi Germany

    By Kiyoshi Takenaka TOKYO (Reuters) - Philippine President Benigno Aquino made a veiled comparison on Wednesday between China's activities in the South China Sea and Nazi Germany's expansionism before World War Two, echoing similar remarks he made last year that outraged Beijing. Aquino, who is expected to agree beefed up defence ties with Japan when he meets Prime Minister Shinzo Abe on Thursday, also urged Beijing to rethink its land reclamation projects in the disputed waters. China has …

  • In Tokyo, Philippine leader criticizes China over sea moves
    In Tokyo, Philippine leader criticizes China over sea moves

    TOKYO (AP) — On his sixth visit to Japan in five years, Philippine President Benigno Aquino III on Wednesday criticized China's assertiveness in regional seas, a concern shared by both countries as they deepen their ties. …

  • Phl-Japan ties key to maritime security – Noy
    Phl-Japan ties key to maritime security – Noy

    The Philippines has a vital role to play with Japan in defending maritime security and in keeping stability in the region amid tension stirred by China’s rapid land reclamation activities in disputed waters, President Aquino told the Japanese parliament yesterday. “The prosperity of maritime and coastal East and Southeast Asia, which relies greatly on the free movement of goods and peoples, is at risk of being disrupted by attempts to redraw the geographic limits and entitlements outside those …

  • US turns over $1.3 M seized from ex-AFP comptroller
    US turns over $1.3 M seized from ex-AFP comptroller

    United States Ambassador Philip Goldberg personally handed a ceremonial check worth more than $1.384 million or P60.9 million to the Philippine government yesterday representing proceeds of the forfeiture of US assets of former Armed Forces of the Philippines (AFP) comptroller Carlos Garcia. Ombudsman Conchita Carpio-Morales accepted the money, which will be given to the Bureau of Treasury (BTr) as part of the recovered unexplained wealth of Garcia, a former military general still facing …

  • Gov’t lifts deployment ban to Liberia
    Gov’t lifts deployment ban to Liberia

    The Philippine government will resume deployment of Filipino workers to Liberia, which has been declared free of the Ebola virus, an official said yesterday. The Philippine Overseas Employment Administration (POEA) governing board, “in a resolution, resolved to lift the ban in Liberia and to resume processing and deployment of all Filipino workers, including both vacationing and new hires,” Labor Secretary Rosalinda Baldoz said. …

  • Iloilo to host Independence Day rites
    Iloilo to host Independence Day rites

    Departing from tradition, this year’s 117th Independence Day ceremonies will be held not in Luzon but in Iloilo’s Sta. Barbara town, where the Philippine flag was first raised to inaugurate the provisional revolutionary government of the Visayas in 1898. “Let us make use of that momentous event to show this nation the soaring aspirations of Ilonggos – that with our past, present and near future achievements, we are poised to reclaim Iloilo’s rightful place as Queen City of the South,” Drilon …

  • US returns $1 million forfeited from Filipino ex-general

    MANILA, Philippines (AP) — The United States returned to the Philippine government on Wednesday more than $1 million from the forfeited assets of a discharged Filipino general accused of stashing illegally obtained wealth in America. …

  • Japan, Philippines huddle amid increasing China concerns
    Japan, Philippines huddle amid increasing China concerns

    The Philippine president is on his sixth visit to Japan in less than five years, signaling his country's deepening ties with Tokyo amid increasing concerns by both sides about China's assertiveness in ... …

POLL

Should Aquino be held accountable over the Mamasapano operations?

Loading...
Poll Choice Options