The Inbox

National hero not a fan of China

By Carlo Figueroa, VERA Files

Compilation of Rizal's lettersJose Rizal, the country's national hero, avoided Chinese-made products like the plague.

That is the observation one can make upon reading his letters that have been published by the National Historical Commission of the Philippines.

In a letter to his mother Teodora Alonzo dated Oct. 22, 1895, Rizal wrote, "I vowed not to buy anymore from them (Chinese), so that sometimes I find myself very hard up. Now we have almost neither dishes nor tumblers."

A year earlier, he had written his friend, Austrian scholar Ferdinand Blumentritt, describing how he organized a farmers' cooperative while in exile in Dapitan to empower local traders against their Chinese counterparts:

"Here I have become half physician, half businessman. I have established a commercial company here. I have taught the poor Mindanao folk to unite for trading so that they may become independent and free themselves from the Chinese and thus be less exploited."

Rizal's letter to his motherClaims of Rizal's anti-Chinese sentiment are not new. Manila-based Chinese-Filipino businessman Alfonso Ang said Rizal's writings are replete with rejection and discrimination against the Chinese. In his essay "Rizal's Chinese Overcoat," Ang explained how Rizal even denied his Chinese ancestry.

Genealogists have traced Rizal's ancestry to Shang Guo village of what is now Jinjiang City in Fujian province in southern China.

Family records show that his paternal great-great-grandfather, Domingo Lam-co (Ke Yinan), was part of the Ke clan. He eventually settled in Laguna in the mid-18th century, married the Sangley or Chinese mestiza Ines de la Rosa, and changed his family name to Mercado, which means market, to match his profession as a merchant.

Decades later, Lam-co's great-grandson, Francisco Mercado, petitioned the courts to change their family name to Rizal after then Governor-General Narciso Claveria ordered families to use last names from an approved list provided by the colonial government. "Rizal" was apparently chosen to suit Mercado's farming business as the name was derived from the Spanish ricial, meaning "green pastures."

Rizal's letter to BlumentrittBoth Rizal's novels—Noli Me Tangere and El Filibusterismo—are known to criticize the incompetence and the corrupt system of governance of the Spanish colonizers back then. However, aside from its stinging rebuke of Spanish rule, the novels had a number of insulting references to the Chinese community in the Philippines.

Ang particularly mentioned the character of Quiroga in El Filibusterismo and went on to identify the real person behind it. "Quiroga, the subject of Chapter 16 of the El Filibusterismo, 'The Tribulations of a Chinaman,' was none other than Carlos Palanca (who was then the leader of the Chinese community). Artificial in manner, hypocritical, cunning, a bootlicker of government officials, engaging in business speculations, intent on nothing but profit—such was Rizal's portrayal of Quiroga."

Ang said Rizal's portrayal of Palanca, the gobernadorcillo of Binondo and head of the Gremio de Mestizos (Mestizo Guild), was not without basis. "History clearly records Palanca's involvement in disreputable businesses like opium importation and the monopoly on cockfighting arenas," he said.

Ang points to the cultural and political milieu of Rizal's time as reasons behind his antagonism toward the Chinese. "Most of the Chinese mestizos had already 'forgotten' their Chinese ancestry and had become indistinguishable from the "natives." Moreover, there were significant political, cultural, and economic contradictions between these mestizos and the so-called pure-blooded Chinese," he wrote.

Dr. Caroline Hau of the Center for Southeast Asian Studies at Kyoto University concurs with Ang. In an interview she gave to the Manila Bulletin last year, she explained how Rizal's views of the Chinese were shaped by his "background, his class, his education, and the mores and racial attitudes of the time."

"Anti-Chinese sentiment, especially among mestizos and naturales, was a fact of life in the late 19th century, and you can expect some of these sentiments to color Rizal's portrayals of the Chinese in his novels," she said.

But Teresita Ang-See, an expert on Philippine-Chinese studies and issues, does not view it as anti-Chinese, but more of a general anti-foreign sentiment.

"The turn of the 19th century was a period when most intellectuals, the ilustrados foremost among them, were just starting to develop a national consciousness and staking their claim on the Filipino national identity. They start(ed) to veer away from being Caviteno, Cebuano, Ilocano but learn to assert that they are Filipino," Ang-See said in an email interview.

"Rizal's spurning the Chinese should be seen in that context," she added.

While Ang See admitted that the Chinese during the time of Rizal were profiled as illiterate, barefoot vendors and workers who went around in tattered and dirty clothing, Ang-See saw it as something bigger than racism.

"Rizal's ridicule of these characters should be seen in the context of social class distinctions. Rather than anti-Chinese racism, I see it more as an elitist anti-lower class attitude," she said.

Though some scholars would argue Rizal's regard for the Chinese, Austin Coates' book Rizal: Philippine Nationalist and Martyr tellingly describes how Rizal even protested a document he had to sign before his execution in 1896. The reason for his protest was a reference to him as a "Chinese mestizo." In Leon Ma. Guerrero's The First Filipino, Rizal was adamant in claiming that he was a "pure Filipino" and not a "half-breed."

(VERA Files is put out by veteran journalists taking a deeper look at current issues. Vera is Latin for "true".)

  • Happy Earth Day! The 8 Biggest Mysteries of Our Planet
    Happy Earth Day! The 8 Biggest Mysteries of Our Planet

    When the first Earth Day was held in 1970, geologists were still putting the finishing touches on plate tectonics, the model that explains how the Earth's surface takes shape. For today's Earth day, here are some of Earth's biggest unsolved mysteries. Scientists think Earth was a dry rock after it coalesced 4.5 billion years ago. But the beginnings of Earth's water are shrouded in mystery because so little rock evidence remains from this time period. …

  • Angel calls birthday boy Luis ‘amazing’
    Angel calls birthday boy Luis ‘amazing’

    [caption id="attachment_130927" align="alignright" width="300"] Angel Locsin and Luis Manzano (Instagram)[/caption] Angel Locsin is extra sweet to boyfriend Luis Manzano today, with the latter commemorating his 33rd birthday. The actress authorized Sagip Kapamilya Foundation to auction the 1970 Chevrolet Chevelle, which is her dream car. …

  • Miss America defends student suspended for asking her to prom
    Miss America defends student suspended for asking her to prom

    By Chris Francescani NEW YORK (Reuters) - Miss America has suggested officials at a Pennsylvania high school reconsider their decision to suspend a student for approaching her at a school assembly and asking her to be his prom date, the beauty queen said on Saturday. The disciplinary action taken by school administrators in York against the 18-year-old senior made national headlines, and generated sympathy for the young man on social media. A video of Central York High School senior Patrick …

  • Vatican dismisses criticism of John Paul II over abuses
    Vatican dismisses criticism of John Paul II over abuses

    The Vatican on Tuesday brushed off accusations that late pope John Paul II was aware of and ignored allegations about sexual abuse carried by the Mexican founder of a powerful Catholic movement. "There is no personal implication of the Holy Father in this affair," Vatican spokesman Federico Lombardi told a news conference on Sunday's ceremony to confer sainthood on popes John Paul II and John XXIII. The scandal over Marcial Maciel, who founded the Legion of Christ and was a serial predator, …

  • After Oppo, Here Comes Zopo
    After Oppo, Here Comes Zopo

    Oppo, a Chinese mobile phone brand, is bringing to the country the Find 7, Find 7a, Find 5 Mini, N1, R1, and the Neo. A few days after the brand’s launch, NOVO7Tech teased on its Facebook fan page the arrival of another Chinese label, Zopo Mobile. Based in Shenzhen, Zopo Mobile was established in 2012. …

Editor’s note:Yahoo Philippines encourages responsible comments that add dimension to the discussion. No bashing or hate speech, please. You can express your opinion without slamming others or making derogatory remarks.

  • Happy Earth Day! The 8 Biggest Mysteries of Our Planet

    Happy Earth Day! The 8 Biggest Mysteries of Our Planet

    LiveScience.com - 23 hours ago
    Happy Earth Day! The 8 Biggest Mysteries of Our Planet

    When the first Earth Day was held in 1970, geologists were still putting the finishing touches on plate tectonics, the model that explains how the Earth's surface takes shape. For today's Earth day, here are some of Earth's biggest unsolved mysteries. Scientists think Earth was a dry rock after it coalesced 4.5 billion years ago. But the beginnings of Earth's water are shrouded in mystery because so little rock evidence remains from this time period. …

  • David Moyes statement after Man United firing

    David Moyes statement after Man United firing

    Associated Press - 3 hours ago
    David Moyes statement after Man United firing

    MANCHESTER, England (AP) — Statement released by David Moyes on Wednesday, a day after being fired as manager of Manchester United after less than a season in charge. …

  • Pirates kidnap three on Singapore tanker off Malaysia

    Pirates kidnap three on Singapore tanker off Malaysia

    AFP News - 13 hours ago
    Pirates kidnap three on Singapore tanker off Malaysia

    Armed pirates boarded a Singapore-managed oil tanker in the Strait of Malacca, kidnapping three Indonesian crew and stealing some of the vessel's shipment of diesel fuel, the International Maritime Bureau said Wednesday. The attack occurred early Tuesday off Malaysia's west coast, said Noel Choong, head of IMB's Kuala Lumpur-based piracy reporting centre. The diesel oil tanker was believed to be en route to Myanmar. "IMB is aware of the attack on the Singapore-managed ship in the Malacca …

POLL
Loading...
Poll Choice Options