The Inbox

US access talks: it’s PR

Commentary

DND Asst Sec Raymund Jose Quilop, DFA Asst Sec Carlos Sorreta, DND Usec Pio Lorenzo Batino, Justice Usec FranciscoBaraan …

By Ellen Tordesillas

In the media briefing last Monday announcing the start of the talks between the Philippines and the United States on “a possible framework of agreement on the increased rotational presence” of U.S military in the Philippines, the question that was repeatedly asked was, “What does the U.S. wants that the existing Visiting Forces Agreement does not cover?”

The VFA is an agreement between the Philippines and the United States regarding the treatment of U.S. Armed Forces Visiting the Philippines. It was signed in 1998 by Foreign Secretary Domingo Siazon and U.S. Ambassador Thomas Hubbard and ratified by the Philippine Senate.

It covers a whole range of issues including the contentious criminal jurisdiction. It does not set a limit to the number of American visiting troops in the country and their length of stay.

This was how Foreign Affairs Assistant Secretary Carlos Sorreta and Defense Undersecretary Pio Lorenzo, both members of the negotiating panel, Batino answered the question:

Question: Preliminary negotiations; requirements identified by both side that made them decide to come up with framework agreement; requirements that are not covered by VFA and TOR (Terms of Agreement) that necessitate this separate framework agreement.

Sorreta: We are not renegotiating the VFA in this process. We are having consultations regarding the VFA separately, incidentally with the same person, Amb. Eric John he is in charge.

(We will) try to come up with guidelines that will clarify some of the issues particularly raised by the Supreme Court so we are not reinventing anything,… Ii think we will do a briefing on VFA soon, separately.

Question: Why the need for a separate agreement?

Batino: We have seen in the past that when countries execute agreement, they build greater momentum to the strengthening of their relationship. In this case we, both countries would want a strengthening of the alliance to the execution of this agreement, executing defense and military agreements strengthens alliances. It is a position of the department that a stronger alliance with the US creates a stronger defense posture for the Philippines.

Sorreta: If I may add to that when we agreed on a policy with the United States on increased rotational presence, you have been hearing about this policy for past years so we are now going to be institutionalizing this policy. The contemplated format agreement will indicate what are the activities under increased rotational presence, when you talk about increased rotational presence, it seems a good policy but still abstract. We are going to put down on paper what can be done, what can’t be done, where it will be done, where it should not be done, you are going to see eventually modalities like we said parameters and types of activities.

Like what Undersecretary Batino said each activity will be subject to approval, this framework agreement by itself does not authorize any activity, it sets the parameters, it’s up to the Philippines to approve each activity, and if it feels it is to our benefit and it is not detrimental to our interest or to our constitutional laws, then there is that mechanism for approving it.

Batino: May I add something, as pointed out the Mutual Defense Treaty and the VFA have already provided the legal framework covering the temporary presence of US forces in the Philippines and also the corresponding access to facilities, to Philippine facilities. However we can take advantage of this opportunity to provide clearer safeguards for the protection of our national concerns, and these concerns we will discuss with the U.S. panel come negotiations.

Question: What are the things that you can’t do with existing agreements which makes it necessary to enter into new agreement, why need to enter into this one?

Sorreta:I believe that’s been asked and answered but there are things that we can do under the existing the agreements we have, but we have a policy now with the United States on increased rotational presence and we want to institutionalize it.

The Aquino government has already given its consent to the United States and the so-called negotiation is just going through the process. It’s a done deal.

This is just to address criticisms that the government is giving what the Americans want. Which is really the case.

It’s all PR.

  • Pacquiao has lost his 'pop', Mayweather
    Pacquiao has lost his 'pop', Mayweather

    Floyd Mayweather says Manny Pacquiao has lost a step and that the Filipino's superstar slide has coincided with his decision to split from former strength trainer Alex Ariza. The 37-year-old undefeated welterweight champ Mayweather weighed in Wednesday on the latest performance by Pacquiao who beat Timothy Bradley on April 12 in Las Vegas in a rematch of their first bout in June 2012. "Actually, I did watch the fight," said Mayweather who is training to fight Argentina's Marcos Maidana in a …

  • Jodie Foster marries girlfriend
    Jodie Foster marries girlfriend

    Jodie Foster has reportedly tied the knot with Alexandra Hedison, who she has been dating for less than a year. …

  • Why You Forget: 5 Strange Facts About Memory

    Although rare, certain activities can result in a temporary memory loss and brain fog, called transient global amnesia. For example, sex has been reported to cause this memory problem, with patients forgetting the past day or so, and having difficulty forming new memories. …

  • 'More Fun in the Philippines' campaign brings more visitors from New Z …
    'More Fun in the Philippines' campaign brings more visitors from New Z …

    More New Zealanders are finding fun in the Philippines, based on recent data revealed by the Department of Tourism. …

  • Eruption now engaged to GF
    Eruption now engaged to GF

    [caption id="attachment_131583" align="alignright" width="240"] Newly engaged couple Eric Tai and Rona Samson; (inset) Samson’s engagement ring (Instagram)[/caption] Eric “Eruption” Tai has already proposed to his non-showbiz girlfriend Rona Samson. The “It’s Showtime” mainstay offered Samson the ring near Mayon Volcano, Albay over the Holy week break. Tai shared during Monday’s episode of “It’s Showtime,” how he asked Samson the big question. “Umakyat kami, siyempre Eruption at Mayon Volcano. …

Editor’s note:Yahoo Philippines encourages responsible comments that add dimension to the discussion. No bashing or hate speech, please. You can express your opinion without slamming others or making derogatory remarks.

  • Pacquiao has lost his 'pop', Mayweather

    Pacquiao has lost his 'pop', Mayweather

    AFP News - 11 hours ago
    Pacquiao has lost his 'pop', Mayweather

    Floyd Mayweather says Manny Pacquiao has lost a step and that the Filipino's superstar slide has coincided with his decision to split from former strength trainer Alex Ariza. The 37-year-old undefeated welterweight champ Mayweather weighed in Wednesday on the latest performance by Pacquiao who beat Timothy Bradley on April 12 in Las Vegas in a rematch of their first bout in June 2012. "Actually, I did watch the fight," said Mayweather who is training to fight Argentina's Marcos Maidana in a …

  • Eruption now engaged to GF

    Eruption now engaged to GF

    MB - Wed, Apr 23, 2014
    Eruption now engaged to GF

    [caption id="attachment_131583" align="alignright" width="240"] Newly engaged couple Eric Tai and Rona Samson; (inset) Samson’s engagement ring (Instagram)[/caption] Eric “Eruption” Tai has already proposed to his non-showbiz girlfriend Rona Samson. The “It’s Showtime” mainstay offered Samson the ring near Mayon Volcano, Albay over the Holy week break. Tai shared during Monday’s episode of “It’s Showtime,” how he asked Samson the big question. “Umakyat kami, siyempre Eruption at Mayon Volcano. …

  • Happy Earth Day! The 8 Biggest Mysteries of Our Planet

    Happy Earth Day! The 8 Biggest Mysteries of Our Planet

    LiveScience.com - Tue, Apr 22, 2014
    Happy Earth Day! The 8 Biggest Mysteries of Our Planet

    When the first Earth Day was held in 1970, geologists were still putting the finishing touches on plate tectonics, the model that explains how the Earth's surface takes shape. For today's Earth day, here are some of Earth's biggest unsolved mysteries. Scientists think Earth was a dry rock after it coalesced 4.5 billion years ago. But the beginnings of Earth's water are shrouded in mystery because so little rock evidence remains from this time period. …

POLL
Loading...
Poll Choice Options