CA junks case vs Suarez

Manila, Philippines -- The Court of Appeals (CA) has upheld the decision of the Office of the President (OP) to dismiss the administrative charges filed against Quezon Province Governor David Suarez and affirm the exclusive power of the governor to enter into contract on behalf of the province of Quezon.

In a 15-page decision penned by Associate Justice Magdangal M. De Leon, the CA's eleventh division dismissed the petition of Quezon province Vice Governor Vicente Alcala who sought for the reversal of the November 28, 2011 decision of the OP after the agency exonerated Suarez from administrative liabilities as a result of the passage of Resolution No. 2011-750.

Resolution No. 2011-750 amended Resolution Nos. 2011-692 to 701 and granted Suarez the ''sole authority to sign for and in behalf of the Province of Quezon with respect to the different MOAs [memorandum of agreements] by removing the provisions which included petitioner [Mr. Alcala] as a witness and co-signatory thereto.''

''Charged based on mere suspicion and speculation... cannot be given credence,'' the court said.
Apart from Suarez, the administrative case filed against the nine members of the Sangguniang Panlalawigan ng lalawigan ng Quezon were also dismissed. Members of the Sangguniang Panlalawigan were Romano C. Talaga, Teresita O. Dator, Lourdes C. De Luna-Pasatiempo, Victor A. Reyes, Manuel M. Butardo, Gerald D. Ortiz, Rachel A. Ubana, Joanna Rose K. Martija, and the governor's brother Donaldo C. Suarez.

Concurring with the decision were Associate Justices Stephen C. Cruz and Myra V. Garcia-Fernandez.

In affirming the decision of the OP to dismiss the administrative case against the governor, the CA division stressed that Mr. Alcala's inclusion as a co-signatory and as a witness to various MOAs ''constitute[s] undue interference with the functions of the local chief executive.''

Citing Section 465, Article 1, Chapter 3 of the Local Government Code of 1990, the CA division said the provincial governor shall ''represent the province in all its business transactions and sign in its behalf all bonds, contracts, and obligations, and such other documents upon authority of the Sangguniang Panlalawigan [Provincial Council] or pursuant to law or ordinance.''

The appeals court said that the Sangguniang Panlalawigan, as the province's legislative body, has the power to authorize the provincial governor to, among other things, negotiate and contract loans and lease public buildings to private parties as mandated by Republic Act 7160 or the Local Government Code of 1991.

Alcala filed a complaint on Sept. 3, 2011 before the OP ordering the suspension of Mr. Suarez and the nine board members for allegedly passing Resolution No. 2011-750 in an illegal manner.
The vice-governor said the resolution was passed in a special session without his consent as the Sangguniang's presiding officer.

He said that his inclusion as a co-signatory in business contracts serves as an ''anticipatory corruption-proof measure sanctioned by the LGC.''

The CA said that ''what is indispensable is the authorization of the Sangguniand as a collegial body and not the separate authorization or consent of the Vice Governor,'' adding that Alcala ''had already given his prior authorization to the Governor to enter into contracts with various government agencies.''

The appeals court said Alcala failed to show evidence that the special session called for by Suarez to pass Resolution No. 2011-750 was done with malice, corrupt practice, or in bad faith.


Editor’s note:Yahoo Philippines encourages responsible comments that add dimension to the discussion. No bashing or hate speech, please. You can express your opinion without slamming others or making derogatory remarks.

  • Ex-Cavite governor gets PCSO top post
    Ex-Cavite governor gets PCSO top post

    After nearly a year, President Aquino finally made good his promise to a long-time ally – former Cavite governor and congressman Erineo Maliksi – to head the Philippine Charity Sweepstakes Office (PCSO), replacing Margarita Juico who resigned in May 2014. Maliksi must be officially elected by the PCSO board members as their chairman. Prior to his appointment to the PCSO, Maliksi faced graft charges before the Sandiganbayan in connection with the alleged illegal purchase of P2.5 million worth …

  • US, Phl military exercises to focus on sea defense
    US, Phl military exercises to focus on sea defense

    A massive deployment of aircraft, personnel and warships characterizes this year’s Balikatan between the two allies, which war games were launched 30 years ago. Commander Lued Lincuna, Philippine Navy public affairs chief, said the Marine Battalion Landing Team-4 (MBLT-4) will link  up with the US 3rd Marine Expeditionary Force. …

  • P-Noy seeking united Asean stand on China
    P-Noy seeking united Asean stand on China

    With China’s actions threatening to “considerably alter the way of doing business globally,” President Aquino will ask the Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN) to take a united stand against Beijing’s massive reclamation activities and other provocative acts in the West Philippine Sea and South China Sea. Aquino will raise the appeal to his ASEAN counterparts when they meet on April 27-28 in Kuala Lumpur and Langkawi in Malaysia. Beijing reacted immediately to the plan, saying the …

  • OIC exec backs BBL, says passage to end extremism
    OIC exec backs BBL, says passage to end extremism

    The Organization of Islamic Cooperation (OIC) yesterday backed the proposed Bangsamoro Basic Law (BBL), warning that failure to see the peace process through with the Moro Islamic Liberation Front (MILF) could open the door to extremism. OIC secretary-general Iyad Bin Amin Madani, who is in the country to rally support for the peace process and the BBL, told reporters at the Senate yesterday that the Philippines should not waste the opportunity to attain lasting peace in Mindanao, especially …

  • Senate plan to probe corruption in judiciary opposed
    Senate plan to probe corruption in judiciary opposed

    The head of the Integrated Bar of the Philippines (IBP) is opposing the plan of the Senate to investigate alleged “justice for sale” in the judiciary. In an interview yesterday, IBP national president Vicente Joyas contested the pronouncement of Senate President Franklin Drilon that the Senate Blue Ribbon committee can probe the reported corruption in the judiciary, as it remains part of the scope of the Senate’s investigative power. “The plan of the Senate to push through with the …

  • PNP: Floyd camp charging P.2 M for pay-per-view
    PNP: Floyd camp charging P.2 M for pay-per-view

    The camp of Floyd Mayweather is reportedly charging the Philippine National Police P200,000 for a pay-per-view deal of his fight with Manny Pacquiao, a PNP official said yesterday. Director Danilo Constantino, the PNP’s Chief Directorial Staff, said the cost of the pay-per-view for the fight makes it difficult for the PNP to sponsor the free viewing for its personnel and their dependents at Camp Crame’s multi-purpose center. “We are currently negotiating for the pay-per-view and we ever …

  • No disruption in gun permit issuance – PNP
    No disruption in gun permit issuance – PNP

    There has been no disruption in the issuance of permits to carry firearms outside residence (PTCFOR) since former Philippine National Police (PNP) chief Director General Alan Purisima was suspended in December 2014, an official said yesterday. PNP officer-in-charge Deputy Director General Leonardo Espina is the one signing the PTCFOR cards, PNP spokesman Chief Superintendent Generoso Cerbo Jr. said. Cerbo, however, could not say when Espina started signing the cards and how many PTCFORs have …

  • HK pol calls Pinay maids ‘home wreckers’
    HK pol calls Pinay maids ‘home wreckers’

    A senior Hong Kong politician is under fire after she accused some Filipina domestic helpers of seducing their male employers, in comments branded “racist” and “offensive” by critics. There are 300,000 maids in Hong Kong, mostly from the Philippines and Indonesia, with concern growing among rights groups over their welfare following a string of abuse cases. But lawmaker Regina Ip, a close adviser to the city’s leader Leung Chun-ying and tipped as a future chief executive, cast the maids as …


Should Aquino be held accountable over the Mamasapano operations?

Poll Choice Options