CA junks case vs Suarez

Manila, Philippines -- The Court of Appeals (CA) has upheld the decision of the Office of the President (OP) to dismiss the administrative charges filed against Quezon Province Governor David Suarez and affirm the exclusive power of the governor to enter into contract on behalf of the province of Quezon.

In a 15-page decision penned by Associate Justice Magdangal M. De Leon, the CA's eleventh division dismissed the petition of Quezon province Vice Governor Vicente Alcala who sought for the reversal of the November 28, 2011 decision of the OP after the agency exonerated Suarez from administrative liabilities as a result of the passage of Resolution No. 2011-750.

Resolution No. 2011-750 amended Resolution Nos. 2011-692 to 701 and granted Suarez the ''sole authority to sign for and in behalf of the Province of Quezon with respect to the different MOAs [memorandum of agreements] by removing the provisions which included petitioner [Mr. Alcala] as a witness and co-signatory thereto.''

''Charged based on mere suspicion and speculation... cannot be given credence,'' the court said.
Apart from Suarez, the administrative case filed against the nine members of the Sangguniang Panlalawigan ng lalawigan ng Quezon were also dismissed. Members of the Sangguniang Panlalawigan were Romano C. Talaga, Teresita O. Dator, Lourdes C. De Luna-Pasatiempo, Victor A. Reyes, Manuel M. Butardo, Gerald D. Ortiz, Rachel A. Ubana, Joanna Rose K. Martija, and the governor's brother Donaldo C. Suarez.

Concurring with the decision were Associate Justices Stephen C. Cruz and Myra V. Garcia-Fernandez.

In affirming the decision of the OP to dismiss the administrative case against the governor, the CA division stressed that Mr. Alcala's inclusion as a co-signatory and as a witness to various MOAs ''constitute[s] undue interference with the functions of the local chief executive.''

Citing Section 465, Article 1, Chapter 3 of the Local Government Code of 1990, the CA division said the provincial governor shall ''represent the province in all its business transactions and sign in its behalf all bonds, contracts, and obligations, and such other documents upon authority of the Sangguniang Panlalawigan [Provincial Council] or pursuant to law or ordinance.''

The appeals court said that the Sangguniang Panlalawigan, as the province's legislative body, has the power to authorize the provincial governor to, among other things, negotiate and contract loans and lease public buildings to private parties as mandated by Republic Act 7160 or the Local Government Code of 1991.

Alcala filed a complaint on Sept. 3, 2011 before the OP ordering the suspension of Mr. Suarez and the nine board members for allegedly passing Resolution No. 2011-750 in an illegal manner.
The vice-governor said the resolution was passed in a special session without his consent as the Sangguniang's presiding officer.

He said that his inclusion as a co-signatory in business contracts serves as an ''anticipatory corruption-proof measure sanctioned by the LGC.''

The CA said that ''what is indispensable is the authorization of the Sangguniand as a collegial body and not the separate authorization or consent of the Vice Governor,'' adding that Alcala ''had already given his prior authorization to the Governor to enter into contracts with various government agencies.''

The appeals court said Alcala failed to show evidence that the special session called for by Suarez to pass Resolution No. 2011-750 was done with malice, corrupt practice, or in bad faith.


Editor’s note:Yahoo Philippines encourages responsible comments that add dimension to the discussion. No bashing or hate speech, please. You can express your opinion without slamming others or making derogatory remarks.

  • Philippines backs support for small enterprises at APEC meet

    MANILA, Philippines (AP) — The Philippines' top trade official on Saturday called for support for the integration of micro, small and medium enterprises in global trade, which he said would help reduce poverty and inequality in the Asia-Pacific region. …

  • US renews travel warning to Mindanao
    US renews travel warning to Mindanao

    The US State Department renewed its warning about the risks of travel to the Philippines, in particular to the Sulu archipelago, certain regions and cities of Mindanao and the southern Sulu Sea area. In an update on Wednesday of a travel warning it issued Nov. 20, 2014, the State Department said US citizens should continue to defer non-essential travel to the Sulu archipelago due to the high threat of kidnapping of international travelers and violence linked to insurgency and terrorism there. …

  • Phl gains support for APEC Action Agenda
    Phl gains support for APEC Action Agenda

    The Philippine initiative to put the interests of micro, small and medium enterprises (MSMEs) front and center in global and regional trade has made significant progress following the conclusion on Thursday of the 2nd APEC Senior Officials’ Meeting (SOM2) and Related Meetings in Boracay, Aklan. Called “The Boracay Action Agenda to Globalize MSMEs,” the Philippine proposal calls for a host of specific, concrete and practical interventions that APEC economies can implement to provide MSMEs wider …

  • Phl to join Bangkok meet on Rohingya crisis next week
    Phl to join Bangkok meet on Rohingya crisis next week

    The Philippines will join a 15-nation meeting in Bangkok, Thailand next week to address the migration crisis involving thousands of Rohingyas who escaped persecution in Myanmar and Bangladesh. Justice Secretary Leila de Lima bared this yesterday after meeting with United Nations High Commission for Refugees (UNHCR) representative to the Philippines Bernard Kerblat. In an interview, De Lima said the Philippine government has been invited to the meeting. …

  • Magnitude 4.2 quake jolts Sorsogon
    Magnitude 4.2 quake jolts Sorsogon

    LEGAZPI CITY—A magnitude 4.2 earthquake hit Prieto Diaz town in Sorsogon before dawn yesterday, the Philippine Institute of Volcanology and Seismology (Phivolcs) said. …

  • Drought-resistant rice breeds bared
    Drought-resistant rice breeds bared

    SCIENCE CITY OF MUÑOZ, Nueva Ecija – Amid the searing heat, the Philippine Rice Research Institute central experiment station here has identified nine rice breeds which have been proven to be drought-resistant and produce high yields in temperatures as high as 38°C based on a recent study. Thelma Padolina, lead researcher of the study titled “Screening of rice-induced mutants for heat and drought tolerance,” identified the breeding lines as the Ballatinaw lines, PSB Rc72H and Azucena lines. …

  • Phl, US assert rights, ignore China warning
    Phl, US assert rights, ignore China warning

    The United States military will continue air and sea patrols in international waters even after the Chinese navy repeatedly warned a US surveillance plane to leave the airspace over artificial islands China is creating in the disputed South China Sea. The Philippine government also declared it would continue activities in the region, calling on China to respect freedom of navigation and aviation. “Our position on the importance of letting freedom of navigation, freedom of aviation and …

  • MM shutdown eyed for quake drill; 6 schools warned
    MM shutdown eyed for quake drill; 6 schools warned

    Electricity and mobile phone services would be cut throughout Metro Manila, and all private and government offices and businesses, including shopping malls, would be closed. That would be the situation on July 16 between 3 and 8 p.m. to simulate the scenario of a 7.2 magnitude earthquake. The Philippine Institute of Volcanology and Seismology (Phivolcs) has warned that an earthquake of that magnitude could occur and kill at least 33,500 people and injure at least 113,600 others following a …


Should Aquino be held accountable over the Mamasapano operations?

Poll Choice Options