Enrile quizzes defense, prosecution on 'culpa'

After the prosecution and defense teams delivered their closing arguments on Monday, Senate Juan Ponce Enrile quizzed both parties about a Latin law term which may decide the fate of the impeachment case.
 
“What is culpa?” Enrile asked the two parties.
 
Lead defense counsel Serafin Cuevas, who seemed unsure of his answer, said, “Maybe I was absent when it was discussed in school.”
 
“That's your bad luck,” Enrile replied.
 
Prosecutor Ilocos Norte Rep. Rudy Farinas stepped in and answered that culpa is a “willful and intentional violation” of the law.
 
The senate president sitting as presiding officer pointed out that “culpa” is material in considering the Constitutional provision requiring the truthful disclosure of statement of assets, liabilities and net worth.
 
“If complete SALN declaration is a command, does disobedience to it constitute a culpable violation?
 
“It does not call for any intent. Where in that provision do you find intent?” Enrile added.
 
The defense team has insisted that Chief Justice Renato Corona, who is accused of untruthful disclosure of his SALNs, acted on “good faith” when he did not declare his dollar accounts.
 
The defense said Corona merely relied on the absolute confidentiality guaranteed by laws on banking secrecy and foreign currency deposit units, and was not trying to hide his assets.
 
Enrile, however, said depositors can voluntarily disclose their dollar accounts without suffering from penalty.
 
“What injury will be caused if a public officer with foreign currency deposits would declare that deposit in his SALN?
 
“We are forgetting that the law allows exposure of foreign currency deposits if the depositor himself would do it,” he said.
 
Enrile added that third parties, such as banking institutions, are the ones prohibited to reveal foreign currency deposits and not the depositors.

But Cuevas said declaring dollar deposits may put government official at risk of kidnapping or extortion.

If convicted, no more appeal?

Meanwhile, Enrile asserted the sole authority of the Senate over impeachment cases amid reports that the defense team may appeal to the Supreme Court in case Chief Justice Renato Corona is convicted by the impeachment court.
 
“I understand that there was an interview done where you are involved, and that you indicated your resolve to elevate the results of these proceedings to the Supreme Court, is this correct?” Enrile clarified with lead defense counsel Serafin Cuevas.
 
Reading from the transcript of Cuevas’ radio interview, Enrile quoted him as saying, “We have no other alternative but to resort to certiorari. I’ll ask for a petition for review questioning the validity of the actuations of the proceedings with the impeachment court and necessarily with a motion to nullify the entirety of the proceedings that took place therein.
 
“What was written in the Constitution is that the moment the Senate convenes as the impeachment court, it shall continue the trial. There is nothing there that says that the decision shall be final and non-appealable.”
 
Enrile, however, maintained that the SC cannot intervene with the impeachment court’s decision.
 
“We respect your decision but we'd like to remind you that Senate has sole power to try and decide all impeachment cases,” he said.

The Constitution provides that penalty in cases of impeachment shall not extend further than removal from office and disqualification to hold any public office.

Before the impeachment court will render its decision tomorrow, senator-judges will first discuss in a caucus the penalty to be imposed if the court rules against the chief justice.

Loading...

Editor’s note:Yahoo Philippines encourages responsible comments that add dimension to the discussion. No bashing or hate speech, please. You can express your opinion without slamming others or making derogatory remarks.

  • Sy moves up, Villar enters Forbes list of billionaires
    Sy moves up, Villar enters Forbes list of billionaires

    Eleven Filipinos are included in Forbes’ 2015 list of richest people in the world. Filipino-Chinese tycoon Henry Sy Sr. continues to be the wealthiest man in the Philippines. The 90-year-old SM supermalls, banking and property tycoon ranked 73rd among the world’s richest with an increased net worth of $14.2 billion from $11.4 billion last year. Sy’s net worth was attributed to the continued growth of his SM Investments Corp. and his more recent venture, the City of Dreams Manila resort and …

  • Jolo apologizes to Bong in visit
    Jolo apologizes to Bong in visit

    Cavite Vice Gov. Jolo Revilla wept and embraced his father as he apologized for the “accidental” shooting incident in their Ayala Alabang residence, the family’s spokesman said yesterday. Lawyer Raymund Fortun came out of the private room at the Asian Hospital and Medical Center in Muntinlupa City to speak to reporters, who were barred from entering the hospital compound during the visit of Sen. Ramon “Bong” Revilla Jr. …

  • N. Korea fires missiles in anger at South-US military drills
    N. Korea fires missiles in anger at South-US military drills

    North Korea fired two short-range ballistic missiles into the sea and vowed "merciless" retaliation Monday as the US and South Korea kicked off joint military drills denounced by Pyongyang as recklessly confrontational. The annual exercises always trigger a surge in military tensions and warlike rhetoric on the divided peninsula, and analysts saw the North's missile tests as a prelude to a concerted campaign of sabre-rattling. "If there is a particularly sharp escalation, we could see the …

  • No need for Revilla to visit son – prosecutors
    No need for Revilla to visit son – prosecutors

    Instead of filing an opposition, ombudsman prosecutors filed a manifestation yesterday expressing belief that there is no urgent need for Sen. Ramon “Bong” Revilla Jr. to visit his son at the Asian Hospital and Medical Center. “Based on the clinical abstract issued by the Asian Hospital on patient (Cavite) Vice-governor (Jolo) Revilla, which was submitted by accused Revilla in support of his Urgent Motion, Vice-governor Revilla is in stable condition and has stable vital signs, as of March 1, …

  • Australian drug smugglers being taken to Indonesian island for execution - media
    Australian drug smugglers being taken to Indonesian island for execution - media

    By Jane Wardell and Beawiharta SYDNEY/DENPASAR, Indonesia (Reuters) - Two convicted Australian drug smugglers were removed from a prison in Bali on Wednesday to be taken to an Indonesian island where they will be shot by firing squad, Australian media reported. The planned executions of Myuran Sukumaran, 33, and Andrew Chan, 31, have ratcheted up diplomatic tensions amid repeated pleas of mercy for the pair from Australia and thrown a spotlight on Indonesia's increasing use of the death …

  • Couple married 67 years holds hands in final hours together
    Couple married 67 years holds hands in final hours together

    FRESNO, Calif. (AP) — After spending 67 years together as devoted husband and wife, there was no question how Floyd and Violet Hartwig would end their lives — together. …

  • Another source of SAF execution video identified
    Another source of SAF execution video identified

    The National Bureau of Investigation (NBI) is still tracing the source of the video showing one of the wounded police commandos being finished off by Muslim rebels during the encounter in Mamasapano, Maguindanao last Jan. 25. A source from the Department of Justice (DOJ) said they have identified two persons who first uploaded the video that went viral over social networking sites. The supposed source of the video was elusive and claimed that somebody just placed it on an external drive. The …

  • How Islamic is Islamic State group? Not very, experts say
    How Islamic is Islamic State group? Not very, experts say

    CAIRO (AP) — Three British schoolgirls believed to have gone to Syria to become "jihadi" brides. Three young men charged in New York with plotting to join the Islamic State group and carry out attacks on American soil. A masked, knife-wielding militant from London who is the face of terror in videos showing Western hostages beheaded. …

POLL

Should Aquino be held accountable over the Mamasapano operations?

Loading...
Poll Choice Options