Enrile quizzes defense, prosecution on 'culpa'

After the prosecution and defense teams delivered their closing arguments on Monday, Senate Juan Ponce Enrile quizzed both parties about a Latin law term which may decide the fate of the impeachment case.
 
“What is culpa?” Enrile asked the two parties.
 
Lead defense counsel Serafin Cuevas, who seemed unsure of his answer, said, “Maybe I was absent when it was discussed in school.”
 
“That's your bad luck,” Enrile replied.
 
Prosecutor Ilocos Norte Rep. Rudy Farinas stepped in and answered that culpa is a “willful and intentional violation” of the law.
 
The senate president sitting as presiding officer pointed out that “culpa” is material in considering the Constitutional provision requiring the truthful disclosure of statement of assets, liabilities and net worth.
 
“If complete SALN declaration is a command, does disobedience to it constitute a culpable violation?
 
“It does not call for any intent. Where in that provision do you find intent?” Enrile added.
 
The defense team has insisted that Chief Justice Renato Corona, who is accused of untruthful disclosure of his SALNs, acted on “good faith” when he did not declare his dollar accounts.
 
The defense said Corona merely relied on the absolute confidentiality guaranteed by laws on banking secrecy and foreign currency deposit units, and was not trying to hide his assets.
 
Enrile, however, said depositors can voluntarily disclose their dollar accounts without suffering from penalty.
 
“What injury will be caused if a public officer with foreign currency deposits would declare that deposit in his SALN?
 
“We are forgetting that the law allows exposure of foreign currency deposits if the depositor himself would do it,” he said.
 
Enrile added that third parties, such as banking institutions, are the ones prohibited to reveal foreign currency deposits and not the depositors.

But Cuevas said declaring dollar deposits may put government official at risk of kidnapping or extortion.

If convicted, no more appeal?

Meanwhile, Enrile asserted the sole authority of the Senate over impeachment cases amid reports that the defense team may appeal to the Supreme Court in case Chief Justice Renato Corona is convicted by the impeachment court.
 
“I understand that there was an interview done where you are involved, and that you indicated your resolve to elevate the results of these proceedings to the Supreme Court, is this correct?” Enrile clarified with lead defense counsel Serafin Cuevas.
 
Reading from the transcript of Cuevas’ radio interview, Enrile quoted him as saying, “We have no other alternative but to resort to certiorari. I’ll ask for a petition for review questioning the validity of the actuations of the proceedings with the impeachment court and necessarily with a motion to nullify the entirety of the proceedings that took place therein.
 
“What was written in the Constitution is that the moment the Senate convenes as the impeachment court, it shall continue the trial. There is nothing there that says that the decision shall be final and non-appealable.”
 
Enrile, however, maintained that the SC cannot intervene with the impeachment court’s decision.
 
“We respect your decision but we'd like to remind you that Senate has sole power to try and decide all impeachment cases,” he said.

The Constitution provides that penalty in cases of impeachment shall not extend further than removal from office and disqualification to hold any public office.

Before the impeachment court will render its decision tomorrow, senator-judges will first discuss in a caucus the penalty to be imposed if the court rules against the chief justice.

Loading...

Editor’s note:Yahoo Philippines encourages responsible comments that add dimension to the discussion. No bashing or hate speech, please. You can express your opinion without slamming others or making derogatory remarks.

  • UN report: More than 25,000 foreigners fight with terrorists
    UN report: More than 25,000 foreigners fight with terrorists

    UNITED NATIONS (AP) — A new U.N. report says more than 25,000 foreign fighters from over 100 countries have traveled to join with al-Qaida, the Islamic State group and other splinter groups in countries from Iraq and Syria to Afghanistan, Libya and the Philippines. …

  • Sandiganbayan allows Sen. Jinggoy to have his aching shoulder checked

    The Sandiganbayan Fifth Division has given permission to Senator Jinggoy Ejercito Estrada to leave detention and have his aching shoulder checked at a private hospital yesterday. "After taking into account the arguments of both parties and for humanitarian considerations, the Court resolves to grant accused-movant's prayer over the objection of the prosecution," read the Fifth Division's resolution that was issued yesterday and signed by its Chairman Roland Jurado and Associate Justices Efren …

  • Financing lack cause of slow e-vehicle program implementation

    The Electric Vehicle Association of the Philippines (EVAP) has blamed the lack of financing for the slow implementation of the environment friendly e-vehicle program in the country. EVAP President Rommel Juan said that EVs are now available all over the Philippines because of the various  private and some local government units programs on the use of e-vehicles. We need funders, financing people or angel investors to come in and tie up with credible and reliable EV players to finally catapult …

  • Exhibit recalls Christ’s passion and death

    Now ongoing at the Palo Municipal Hall grounds is an exhibit of photographs on the passion and death of Jesus Christ. The exhibit which will run until April 6, is dubbed “Pamalandong Photo Exhibit 2015.”  It features old pictures taken during the traditional yearly re-enactment of Christ’s passion and death in the Archdiocese of Palo,  which is the center of Catholic hierarchy in Leyte and Samar. Palo Mayor Remedios L. Petilla opened the photo exhibit with Philippine Councilor League Leyte …

  • The Philippines, another Singapore?

    Bongbong Marcos makes the ludicrous claim that if his father Ferdinand hadn’t been deposed in 1986, we would now be another Singapore, prosperous and orderly. There was no way that turning the Philippines into another Singapore would be possible today, or in the 1980s. The world’s eyes are all on Singapore these days after the passing last week of that city-state’s founding prime minister, Lee Kuan Yew. As Singapore mourns Lee’s death, the world toasts him as a visionary who practically …

  • Armed men burn Philtranco buses in Tacloban

    Fully armed young men burned two Philtranco Bus Company buses in the Philtranco terminal in Barangay 91 Abucay midnight of March 31. Philippine National Police Eastern Visayas Regional Director Chief Supt. Asher A. Dolina has directed Tacloban City Police Director Senior Supt. Domingo Say Cabillan to conduct an immediate and thorough investigation into the burning of the two commercial passenger buses. Dolina said he wants the case probed to determine if the act is part of the usual …

  • Senate to look into Sajahatra program

    Lourdes “Nancy” Binay has asked the Senate to look into the government’s Sajahatra Bangsamoro Program (SBP) - a joint social protection agenda between the government and the Moro Islamic Liberation Front (MILF), which was included in a comprehensive peace agreement entered into by the two parties. Binay noted that while the SBP’s goal was to uplift and develop the health, education, and livelihood conditions of Bangsamoro communities struggling against poverty and conflict, she has been …

  • Save up for Hajj thru Islamic bank’s plan

    To help pilgrims get to Mecca, Saudi Arabia, the Al-Amanah Islamic Investment Bank of the Philippines (AIIBP) has launched the first Pilgrimage Savings Plan (PSP) in the country. Local Muslims have long been studying Malaysia's widely-successful Tabung Haji savings program, and this was the first time a similar initiative was formally introduced in the Philippines. Idiosa B. Ursolino, AIIBP vice president, presented the PSP at a recent international conference on Islamic finance and banking …

POLL

Should Aquino be held accountable over the Mamasapano operations?

Loading...
Poll Choice Options