Enrile quizzes defense, prosecution on 'culpa'

After the prosecution and defense teams delivered their closing arguments on Monday, Senate Juan Ponce Enrile quizzed both parties about a Latin law term which may decide the fate of the impeachment case.
 
“What is culpa?” Enrile asked the two parties.
 
Lead defense counsel Serafin Cuevas, who seemed unsure of his answer, said, “Maybe I was absent when it was discussed in school.”
 
“That's your bad luck,” Enrile replied.
 
Prosecutor Ilocos Norte Rep. Rudy Farinas stepped in and answered that culpa is a “willful and intentional violation” of the law.
 
The senate president sitting as presiding officer pointed out that “culpa” is material in considering the Constitutional provision requiring the truthful disclosure of statement of assets, liabilities and net worth.
 
“If complete SALN declaration is a command, does disobedience to it constitute a culpable violation?
 
“It does not call for any intent. Where in that provision do you find intent?” Enrile added.
 
The defense team has insisted that Chief Justice Renato Corona, who is accused of untruthful disclosure of his SALNs, acted on “good faith” when he did not declare his dollar accounts.
 
The defense said Corona merely relied on the absolute confidentiality guaranteed by laws on banking secrecy and foreign currency deposit units, and was not trying to hide his assets.
 
Enrile, however, said depositors can voluntarily disclose their dollar accounts without suffering from penalty.
 
“What injury will be caused if a public officer with foreign currency deposits would declare that deposit in his SALN?
 
“We are forgetting that the law allows exposure of foreign currency deposits if the depositor himself would do it,” he said.
 
Enrile added that third parties, such as banking institutions, are the ones prohibited to reveal foreign currency deposits and not the depositors.

But Cuevas said declaring dollar deposits may put government official at risk of kidnapping or extortion.

If convicted, no more appeal?

Meanwhile, Enrile asserted the sole authority of the Senate over impeachment cases amid reports that the defense team may appeal to the Supreme Court in case Chief Justice Renato Corona is convicted by the impeachment court.
 
“I understand that there was an interview done where you are involved, and that you indicated your resolve to elevate the results of these proceedings to the Supreme Court, is this correct?” Enrile clarified with lead defense counsel Serafin Cuevas.
 
Reading from the transcript of Cuevas’ radio interview, Enrile quoted him as saying, “We have no other alternative but to resort to certiorari. I’ll ask for a petition for review questioning the validity of the actuations of the proceedings with the impeachment court and necessarily with a motion to nullify the entirety of the proceedings that took place therein.
 
“What was written in the Constitution is that the moment the Senate convenes as the impeachment court, it shall continue the trial. There is nothing there that says that the decision shall be final and non-appealable.”
 
Enrile, however, maintained that the SC cannot intervene with the impeachment court’s decision.
 
“We respect your decision but we'd like to remind you that Senate has sole power to try and decide all impeachment cases,” he said.

The Constitution provides that penalty in cases of impeachment shall not extend further than removal from office and disqualification to hold any public office.

Before the impeachment court will render its decision tomorrow, senator-judges will first discuss in a caucus the penalty to be imposed if the court rules against the chief justice.

Loading...

Editor’s note:Yahoo Philippines encourages responsible comments that add dimension to the discussion. No bashing or hate speech, please. You can express your opinion without slamming others or making derogatory remarks.

  • Philippines to fly over disputed South China Sea: Aquino
    Philippines to fly over disputed South China Sea: Aquino

    Philippine military and commercial aircraft will keep flying over disputed areas in the South China Sea despite Chinese warnings over the airspace, President Benigno Aquino said on Monday. "We will still fly the routes that we fly based on the international law from the various conventions we entered into," Aquino told reporters when asked whether the Philippines accepted China's position. The Chinese military last week ordered a US Navy P-8 Poseidon surveillance plane away from airspace …

  • ‘Kentex owners still in Phl’
    ‘Kentex owners still in Phl’

    The daughter of one of the Kentex Manufacturing Corp. owners has assured the government that the businessmen are still in the Philippines, contrary to some reports that they have fled the country. Barbara Ang, daughter of Kentex shareholder Veato Ang, said her father and his business partners have no plans of leaving the country despite the razing of the Valenzuela slipper factory, which killed 72 workers on May 13. Valenzuela Mayor Rex Gatchalian also stood by his promise to punish any local …

  • Gasoline prices up, diesel down
    Gasoline prices up, diesel down

    Oil companies announced yesterday a price hike of 50 centavos per liter for gasoline and a rollback of 50 centavos per liter for diesel effective at 6 a.m. today. Independent oil firms were among the first to announce the price adjustment. In an advisory, PTT Philippines, the local subsidiary of Thailand’s biggest oil firm said it cut diesel prices by 50 centavos per liter and increased gasoline prices by 50 centavos per liter. …

  • Lawmakers to review building code provisions
    Lawmakers to review building code provisions

    Lawmakers are set to review provisions of the National Building Code and Republic Act 10121, or the Philippine Disaster Risk Reduction and Management Act, to strengthen contingencies and policies to prepare the country for possible major earthquakes. The move came following proposals from Reps. Winston Castelo of Quezon City and Lito Atienza of the Buhay party-list to review the two laws and other regulations during a hearing of the House committee on Metro Manila development on the …

  • Noy: Phl may attain first world status with continued reforms
    Noy: Phl may attain first world status with continued reforms

    The Philippines’ attaining first world status may soon be imminent if significant reforms initiated by the current administration would be consistently pursued, President Aquino suggested yesterday. “Kung madidiligan ang ating mga pinunla, at makaka-graduate ang mga pinag-aaral natin upang makapasok sa maaayos na trabaho, baka po tuluyan nang nasa first world status tayo sa panahong iyon (If we water the seeds sown and those we sent to school will find better jobs, then time will come that …

  • Phl won’t recognize China air restrictions
    Phl won’t recognize China air restrictions

    The Philippines will not recognize restrictions on air and sea travel set by China in the West Philippine Sea, President Aquino said yesterday. “We will still fly the routes that we fly based on international law and the various conventions, agreements that have been entered into through various decades,” Aquino told reporters in an ambush interview after inspecting the Marikina Elementary School in preparation for the opening of classes in June. “Maybe we should not think about getting …

  • Rainy season likely in 2nd week of June
    Rainy season likely in 2nd week of June

    Filipinos may have to wait until the second or third week of June for rain, the Philippine Atmospheric, Geophysical and Astronomical Services Administration (PAGASA) said yesterday. Rene Paciente, chief of PAGASA’s marine meteorological services section, said they expect the rainy season to start in the second or third week of June. The criteria for declaring the onset of the rainy season include the prevalence of the southwest monsoon and the 25-millimeter rainfall recorded in at least five …

  • UN urged to probe torture cases under Noy’s term
    UN urged to probe torture cases under Noy’s term

    The United Nations has been asked to look into   110 cases of torture and numerous cases of illegal arrests during the Aquino administration. Cristina Palabay, Karapatan secretary-general, yesterday said the matter could be looked into when the United Nations Subcommittee on Prevention of Torture (SPT) visits from May 25 to June 3 to monitor the  implementation of the Optional protocol to the Convention Against Torture (OpCAT), which the Philippines ratified in 2012. “We enjoin the UN SPT to …

POLL

Should Aquino be held accountable over the Mamasapano operations?

Loading...
Poll Choice Options