Kasambahay Law: Boon or Bane?

The provisions of the Kasambahay Law (R.A. 10381) and its accompanying Implementing Rules and Regulations (IRR) constitute a boon for several government entities apparently looking for ways to improve their coffers, a questionable boon for domestic workers, and definitely a bane for employers of these domestic workers, most of whom are themselves mere employees or struggling entrepreneurs. Most definitely it is a boon to our brilliant lawmakers who without considering the difficulties of its implementation, have passed it as a great political statement that indeed they are for the poor, and do vote for us next election.

Are kasambahays voters? Most of them I believe are not. Are harassed housewives employing kasambahays voters? Many of them are, and I wonder if they are happy with the author of that law, which constitutes a heavy burden on them. This burden of course is something the honorable author of that bill would never feel, especially since he is not one struggling to make ends meet, and as he most likely has pork against which to dip to pay for his maids, gardeners, drivers, etc.

Of course, the law obviously is intended to protect house workers from being exploited or from harm. But I seriously doubt if most kasambahays are treated shamefully. Culturally, Filipino employers, who are called "ate" or "kuya," treat their househelp like members of the family, and tell their children to likewise call their yayas by the respectful title of "ate" also. They bring their help along on trips out of town, seat them with the family when they eat out and some do even in their home. Filipino families, especially the middle class and the slightly lower middle class, know the value of their kasambahays to whom they leave charge of their homes and children, when they themselves are struggling on salaries that barely cover their mortgages, school expenses for their children, the cost of transportation and daily subsistence what with prices of food and commodities moving inexorably higher each time they go to market or to the groceries, notwithstanding press releases that inflation is "contained."

The law is unjust to the heavily burdened middle class in terms of the additional expenses that have been laid on their shoulders - SSS contributions, PagIBIG and Philhealth, which of course would go up proportionately as they increase the wages of their househelp, which many of them do every year in appreciation for the services rendered their families. What is worse, is that they have to themselves go to these bureaucracy-laden government agencies to register their househelp, thus missing at least three days, one for each agency, of work themselves. Try going to any of these agencies and see if you can get anything done in an hour - you need to take a leave for each of these tasks that the law imposes on them. This is not to mention the bureaucratic requirement for regular reports that have to be submitted!

The prescription for minimum wage for the kasambahay differs from area to area, but if you ask any employer, especially those in Metro Manila, they give wages higher than that prescribed. The additional cost to them for SSS, Philhealth and Pagibig which they must shoulder is unfair - employees in offices or factories are deducted for those and the employer only pays a share. Indeed, some families may opt to reduce the number of help they have, or do without altogether. So where is the boon to those who have no other skills to offer.

Another problem many kasambahay employers have to contend with is that most of them get their maids through employment agencies which charge fantastic fees with a promise for one replacement if the one they provide does not fulfil her contract, who leave after a month or even less with flimsy excuses, which agencies deploy to another unknowing employer. The one replacement is the only solace an employer has, except, guess what: The replacement also leaves after a short while, and thus no more replacement, pay a new fee if you need another one. I sometimes have wondered whether there is some kind of understanding or collusion between the agencies and the helpers they deploy. I also think that it should be the duty of the employment agency, considering the hefty fees they charge, to make sure that the maids they deploy already have memberships in those government agencies, so that at least the employer need be faced only with the payments. This should have been provided in the law or the IRR.

But assuming that indeed, the employer gets a jewel who stays with them, who feels a part of the family - is she happy about the provision about a weekly day off, that she works for only 8 hours and more than that must get "overtime"? How do you measure the number of hours that the kasambahay renders - the regulation apparently forbids making them work very early - but their employers themselves have to go to work (most of whom have to commute, since they don't have government-issued vehicles and drivers), have to send their children to school, and so preparing breakfast and "baon" have to be done pretty early. What constitutes "overtime"? Housework cannot be measured like work in an office or factory which have set hours of work...housework is done in batches...morning preparations, cleaning, and cooking, with moments, even hours in between to rest or even take a siesta until it's time again to prepare for dinner. As for the weekly day off, I know that most maids do not like to go out every week - "gastos" they say, and they would rather stay at home where they are sure to have food and lodging at no additional cost to them. They normally prefer a vacation of about two or three weeks, for which they save part of their wages, and if indeed they have been loyal and trustworthy, they are usually allowed paid vacations.

Boon or bane? This to my mind is again another example of laws that are passed without proper consultation with all those who would be affected, especially the employers of kasambahay, as well as it has been passed and approved without the proper assistance to employers in the matter of the bureaucratic things they have to endure.



Editor’s note:Yahoo Philippines encourages responsible comments that add dimension to the discussion. No bashing or hate speech, please. You can express your opinion without slamming others or making derogatory remarks.

  • China says Philippines violating South China Sea code

    China has accused the Philippines of violating a 13-year-old informal code of conduct in the South China Sea with its building work on disputed islets, firing back again after repeated criticism of China's own construction work. China and the 10-member Association of South East Asian Nations (ASEAN) signed an agreement in 2002 to refrain from occupying uninhabited reefs and shoals in the sea, and from building new structures that would complicate disputes. In a statement just before midnight …

  • Mineski’s 2015 SEA grand finals to be held in Malaysia

    Twelve teams from seven countries will be participating in this year’s Mineski Pro-Gaming League South-East Asian Grand Finals (MPGL7 SEA Grand Finals), set to take place from May 9-10. For the first time, the finals will be held outside of the Philippines, instead taking place in Selangor, Malaysia as part of the 2015 Selangor Cyber Games. “The decision to move the grand finals from PH to Malaysia came into mind last year, right after the Season 6 grand finals,” said Marlon Marcelo, …

  • SE Asia Stocks-Mostly up; Philippines, Vietnam outperform on financials

    May 5 (Reuters) - Southeast Asian stock markets mostly ended firmer on Tuesday, bucking the regional trend on slowing growth in China, while Philippine and Vietnam shares outperformed the region, led by ... …

  • Pacquiao-Mayweather fight temporarily knocked out air pollution in NCR

    Manny Pacquiao’s fight against Floyd Mayweather, Jr. not only brought crime rates down, it also inadvertently led to lower levels of air pollution in the metro. It’s always been a running joke how cities in the Philippines grind to a halt whenever Pacquiao has a match. At no time was this more true than this year’s Pacquiao vs. Mayweather fight. Major throughfares like EDSA had been almost completely deserted, enough to cause a measurably significant drop in air pollution. …

  • Strong growth seen in Pinoy S&T workforce

    The number of science and technology (S&T) workers in the Philippines has doubled over the past two decades, according to a recent study by the Science Education Institute of the Department of Science and Technology (DOST-SEI). The study, named “Human Resources in Science and Technology in the Philippines” (HRST), reported that the number of S&T workers in the country grew by 99.17% from 1990 to 2010, growing from 362,000 in 1990 to 593,000 in 2000, up to 721,000 in 2010. The census data used …

  • SE Asia Stocks-Mostly up, Philippines rises on financials

    May 5 (Reuters) - Most Southeast Asian stock markets rose on Tuesday, bucking the regional trend on slowing growth in China, while Philippine shares hit a more than one-week high, led by financials. The ... …

  • NCCA plans to conduct mapping of Pag-Asa Island
    NCCA plans to conduct mapping of Pag-Asa Island

    The National Commission for Culture and the Arts (NCCA) plans to send researchers to conduct a cultural mapping of Pag-Asa Island, which is part of Philippine-held territories in the disputed Spratlys in the West Philippine Sea. Harold Rentoria, NCCA committee on cultural heritage commissioner, admitted that since two years ago they have been thinking of going to Pag-Asa Island for their cultural mapping project. Cultural mapping is part of the NCCA program Taoid – the Ilocano word for …

  • No CNN interview for senators in ‘pork’ scam
    No CNN interview for senators in ‘pork’ scam

    Cable News Network (CNN) Philippines has been denied a chance to interview detained Senators Juan Ponce Enrile, Bong Revilla, and Jinggoy Estrada, a Sandiganbayan justice said yesterday. Sandiganbayan Presiding Justice Amparo Cabotaje-Tang told The STAR CNN’s request for an interview with the lawmakers, who are being held without bail at Camp Crame, will not be allowed as such may violate a rule preventing parties to an ongoing trial from discussing the merits of the case. CNN Philippines had …


Should Aquino be held accountable over the Mamasapano operations?

Poll Choice Options