Kennedy daughter confirms plagiarism complaint vs Sotto

The office of Kerry Kennedy, daughter of the late US senator Robert F. Kennedy (RFK),

has confirmed the authenticity of a strongly worded statement against Senator Vicente "Tito" Sotto III that began to circulate widely on the Internet over the weekend. The statement chastises Sotto for "his unethical, unsanctioned theft of Robert Kennedy's intellectual property and the intellectual property of all those whose work he has plagiarized." The statement, dated November 9, is signed by Ms. Kennedy under the letterhead of the

RFK Center for Justice and Human Rights based in New York, of which she is both founder and president. However, Sotto told reporters on Monday, November 12, that he is still waiting for an official copy of the document to be sent to his office before commenting on the matter. "Bakit ako magrereact, wala ako natatanggap? So no comment... ako [kasi] magiging talking head ng story. Kayo ba may natanggap ba kayo? Bakit pinapatulan ninyo?" he said. GMA News Online received a scanned copy of the statement last Friday, and sought a verification of the document from Meaghan Baron, senior communications strategist at the RFK Center, who replied on Monday morning.

"I passed along your email to Kerry (Kennedy). And yes, I can confirm (Kerry's) letter on Senator Sotto is legitimate," Baron said in response to GMA News Online's inquiry via email.

Comparison of Kennedy's and Sotto's speeches

The "Day of Affirmation" speech was delivered by RFK in South Africa, on June 6, 1966. With its inspirational message of hope to a nation then under apartheid, the speech has since become one of the most famous and most quoted speeches in American politics.

On September 5, 2012, Sotto delivered before the Philippine Senate a speech in Filipino which, observers noted, bore striking similarities to RFK's address. Below is a direct line-by-line comparison of excerpts from Kennedy's speech (in underlined letters) and Sotto's speech (in italic letters):

Few will have the greatness to bend history;

Iilan ang magiging dakila sa pagbali ng kasaysayan,

but each of us can work to change a small portion of the events, subalit bawat isa sa atin ay maaaring kumilos, gaano man kaliit, para ibahin ang takbo ng mga pangyayari.

Thousands of Peace Corps volunteers are making a difference in the isolated villages and the city slums of dozens of countries. (no equivalent)

Thousands of unknown men and women in Europe resisted the occupation of the Nazis and many died, but all added to the ultimate strength and freedom of their countries. (no equivalent)

It is from numberless diverse acts of courage such as these Ang mga hindi-mabilang na iba’t ibang galaw ng katapangan at paninindigan

that the belief that human history is thus shaped. ang humuhubog sa kasaysayan ng sangkatauhan.

Each time a man stands up for an ideal, Tuwing naninindigan tayo para sa isang paniniwala,

or acts to improve the lot of others, tuwing kumikilos tayo para mapabuti ang buhay ng iba,

or strikes out against injustice, tuwing nilalabanan natin ang kawalan ng katarungan,

he sends forth a tiny ripple of hope, nakalilikha tayo ng maliliit na galaw.

and crossing each other from a million different centers of energy and daring those ripples Kapag nagkasama-sama ang mumunting galaw na mga ito,

build a current which can sweep down bubuo ito ng isang malakas na puwersang kayang magpabagsak

the mightiest walls of oppression and resistance. maging ng pinakamatatag na dingding ng opresyon.

Kennedy: Sotto 'distorted' father's speech

In her statement, Kennedy said: "I am particularly offended to see a speech my father gave in support of global human rights distorted by Senator Sotto as an argument against the right to contraception."

"The Day of Affirmation speech is an internationally well-known and frequently referenced piece of American rhetoric. The 'ripple of hope' line in particular is one of Robert Kennedy's best known quotes and it is absurd to suggest that Senator Sotto came up with identical remarks himself," she added.

"This is an argument that has no ethical merit. This is a clear case of plagiarism, and it is my understanding that Senator Sotto has committed similar acts of plagiarism against a series of American writers and speakers," she concluded.

Kennedy was also offended that Sotto had used her father's speech to attack pro-contraceptive legislation.

"Expanding and protecting access to contraception is a global priority I have promoted for years, and limiting that freedom was in no way the topic of the 1966 Day of Affirmation speech," she said.

Sotto: No comment for now

In an interview with reporters on Monday, Sotto said that he will not issue any comment until he receives an official communication from the Kennedy camp.

"Hangga't walang official [communication], don't say a word kasi ano rereact-an mo, baka imbento lang yan ng mga afficionado, mga manipulator sa Internet," he said.

When asked if he would consider issuing a public apology as Kennedy had demanded, Sotto said: "For what? That's [plagiarism accusation] not true."

US bloggers' complaint, Enrile's assertion

Last week, three US bloggers expressed their intent to file a complaint against Sotto before the Senate Committee on Ethics led by Sen. Alan Peter Cayetano.

Dr. Lisandro "Leloy" Claudio of Ateneo de Manila University told GMA News that he, together with other academics, will incorporate the bloggers' collective statement into a formal complaint to be filed before the Senate Ethics Committee on Tuesday, Nov. 13.

Senate President Juan Ponce Enrile, however, said senators cannot be questioned by anybody outside the Senate.

"You cannot be questioned when you say anything here. Constitutional law yun. I said that before not because of any arrogance of power," he said.

"That's the immunity granted by the people." "If you really respect the Constitution, then enforce that rule. If you don't want it, change the system of government or amend the Constitution," he added.

Enrile was referring to

Article 6, Section 11 of the Constitution, which reads in part: "No member shall be questioned nor be held liable in any other place for any speech or debate in Congress or in any committee thereof."

— With reports from Kimberly Tan and TJ Dimacali, GMA News

Loading...

Editor’s note:Yahoo Philippines encourages responsible comments that add dimension to the discussion. No bashing or hate speech, please. You can express your opinion without slamming others or making derogatory remarks.

  • Shorter hours for rail lines tomorrow
    Shorter hours for rail lines tomorrow

    The Metro Rail Transit (MRT), Light Rail Transit (LRT) and the Philippine National Railways (PNR) will have shorter hours tomorrow for the replacement of defective railroad tracks during the Holy Week. …

  • Noy increases allowances for cops, soldiers
    Noy increases allowances for cops, soldiers

    President Aquino has signed a joint congressional resolution raising the daily subsistence allowance for both members of the Armed Forces of the Philippines (AFP) and the Philippine National Police (PNP). Presidential spokesman Edwin Lacierda said Aquino signed last March 27 the merged Joint Resolution 2 of the Senate and Joint Resolution 26 of the House of Representatives. Speaking to reporters, Lacierda yesterday said the daily allowances of police officers and soldiers were raised from P90 …

  • Oil firms raise gas prices today
    Oil firms raise gas prices today

    This year’s Holy Week break will be accompanied by an increase in local pump prices after oil companies announced yesterday a P1.10 per liter hike for gasoline and P0.60 per liter for diesel effective today. “Phoenix Petroleum Philippines will increase the prices of gasoline by P1.10 per liter and diesel by P0.60 per liter effective 6 a.m. of March 31, 2015 to reflect the movements in the prices of refined petroleum products in the international market,” said Phoenix Petroleum, an independent …

  • DFA denies dropping Phl claim to Sabah
    DFA denies dropping Phl claim to Sabah

    The Philippines has never offered to drop its Sabah claim in exchange for Malaysia’s support for Manila’s arbitration case against China over the West Philippine Sea issue, the Department of Foreign Affairs (DFA) said yesterday. “In the context of our friendly bilateral relations, our two countries have been for years exchanging ways on how to address the issue of the extended continental shelf (ECS) in the South China Sea,” Foreign Affairs spokesman Charles Jose said in explaining the DFA’s …

  • Pagcor remits record high P5 B to national treasury
    Pagcor remits record high P5 B to national treasury

    The Philippine Amusement and Gaming Corp. (Pagcor) has remitted P5 billion in cash dividends to the National Treasury, fully settling all its arrears incurred in the last several years. Pagcor chairman and chief executive officer Cristino Naguiat Jr. said with this year’s remittance, the state-owned gaming firm has fully settled all remaining arrears in cash dividends that were incurred by the previous administration since 2005. Pagcor’s cash dividends to the National Treasury under its …

  • Maysak moves closer to Phl
    Maysak moves closer to Phl

    The typhoon with international name Maysak slightly accelerated as it moved closer to the Philippines yesterday, threatening to dump rains over eastern Luzon this weekend, the state weather bureau said. Rene Paciente, senior weather forecaster of the Philippine Atmospheric, Geophysical and Astronomical Services Administration (PAGASA), said Maysak was spotted at 2,175 kilometers east of Mindanao as of 1 p.m. yesterday. Paciente said based on their latest forecast, Maysak is likely to affect …

  • Phl gets P2-B climate projects from Germany
    Phl gets P2-B climate projects from Germany

    The Philippines is getting 41 million euros or around P2 billion from the International Climate Initiative (ICI) of Germany that will fund 10 bilateral projects to address the impact of climate change. Climate Change Commission (CCC) vice chairman Lucille Sering yesterday met with Norbert Gorissen – head of the International Climate Finance of the German Federal Ministry for the Environment, Nature Conservation, Building and Nuclear Safety – to discuss the projects, some of which will be …

  • Metro sizzles at 35º Celsius
    Metro sizzles at 35º Celsius

    While the start of the summer season has yet to be declared by the state weather bureau, Metro Manila experienced its hottest temperature so far this year at 35.1 degrees Celsius last Sunday. Rene Paciente, senior weather forecaster of the Philippine Atmospheric, Geophysical and Astronomical Services Administration (PAGASA), yesterday said the highest temperature was recorded around 3 p.m. at the Science Garden in Quezon City. Meanwhile, PAGASA recorded yesterday the hottest temperature in …

POLL

Should Aquino be held accountable over the Mamasapano operations?

Loading...
Poll Choice Options