OPINION: The agony of Indonesian migrant workers

Jakarta (The Jakarta Post/ANN) - The agonies of Indonesian migrant workers will likely continue as the government has repeatedly failed to manage its overseas labour policy.

In Indonesia, international labour migration has been perceived as a meagre issue by the government both before and after independence. At the beginning of the 20th century (1905) the Dutch introduced internal migration policy (emigratie) to resettle the Javanese to Lampung in South Sumatra in attempt to resolve demographic pressures and the declining welfare of Java's population. Since then, internal migration preoccupied the government policy and continued after independence (transmigrasi).

The emphasis on internal migration policy influenced the thinking of the ruling elite, which has resulted in the overlooking of international migration. Compare us to the Philippines, which has a long tradition of international migration, Indonesia has a relatively limited experience of cross-border labour movement.

The Indonesian government recognised the existence of international labour migration around the mid-1980s when the press began to report the abuses experienced by Indonesian domestic workers in Saudi Arabia.

The reaction of the labour minister at the time, Adm. Sudomo the former head of the Command for Security and Public Order (Kopkamtib), is typical of Indonesian bureaucrats; instead of protecting the vulnerable migrant workers, he accused the press of circulating falsified stories and instructed domestic workers not to talk with the press.

Sudomo's attitude to migrant workers three decades ago is no different today. The Indonesian governments, from Soeharto to Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono, interestingly continue treating overseas labour as a minor issue and perceive the agony of overseas labour as merely an incidental occurrence.

President Yudhoyono on one occasion stated that only 1 per cent of the total overseas migrant workers experienced violence or human right abuses. On a different occasion, House of Representatives speaker Marzuki Alie and head of the special task force created by the president to solve the problem of migrant workers, Maftuh Basyuni, cited the improper behaviour of migrant workers as the source of the problem. Basyuni was a former religious affairs minister and former ambassador to Saudi Arabia.

There is no doubt that the president and his administration neglect the vulnerability of migrant workers and have been non-committal in improving the protection and security of overseas labour.

Interestingly, amid the ad-hoc and reactionary responses by the ruling elites to the problem of overseas labour, the number of people who cross the state's borders to look for jobs has steadily increased. The flow of labour reflects the high demand of workers in the receiving countries and the surplus of labour at the home countries.

The latest economic surveys (The Jakarta Post, November 5, 2012) indicate that domestic job creation is very low although nationally economic growth is relatively high. The flow of labour also indicates that income disparities between Indonesia and the receiving countries remain high. Regretfully, overseas labour has only been given little attention and never integrated into the macroeconomic policy and overall human resource development planning in Indonesia.

A clear and comprehensive overseas labour policy is a long overdue. The migration industry, which for a long time has been left under the control of private agencies and labour brokers, should be regulated - migrant workers are citizens that should be protected by the state.

The current commodification of migrant workers that allows them to enter the international labour market unprotected should be regarded - not only as a violation of human right principles but more importantly - as a violation of the Indonesian Constitution.

A more detailed view on the current situation and condition of overseas labour is important to avoid over generalisations. The receiving countries of Indonesian migrant workers could be categorised into three groups: worst, medium and good, based on irregularities and human right violations experienced by the migrant workers.

Applying this simple categorisation, Saudi Arabia and Malaysia would be under the worst category; while Singapore, Hong Kong and Taiwan would be falling into the medium category; and Japan and South Korea would be under the good category.

The Indonesian government must prioritise its overseas labour policy to be in favour of the receiving countries that, by their domestic social, economic and political natures, treat foreign migrant workers well.

Concerted efforts should be developed within and outside the state's borders - and among the ministries, especially the Home Ministry, Law and Human Rights Ministry, Manpower and Transmigration Ministry and Foreign Ministry - if a viable overseas labour policy with a strong protection component will be formulated. In this effort, civil society organisations experienced in advocating for the improvement of migrant workers' human rights conditions should be consulted in the early stages.

The writer is a researcher at the Indonesian Institute of Sciences. The article was first published at The Jakarta Post on November 26, 2012.

Loading...

Editor’s note:Yahoo Philippines encourages responsible comments that add dimension to the discussion. No bashing or hate speech, please. You can express your opinion without slamming others or making derogatory remarks.

  • First China air force drills in 'far offshore' Pacific
    First China air force drills in 'far offshore' Pacific

    China's air force has carried out its first ever military drill over the western Pacific Ocean, state media said, highlighting Beijing's growing military reach. Several aircraft from China's People's Liberation Army (PLA) on Monday flew over the ocean via the Bashi Channel, which runs between Taiwan and the Philippines, the official Xinhua news agency said. "This is the first time that the PLA Air Force conducted such drills in an airspace far offshore from Chinese coastlines," Xinhua cited …

  • Shorter hours for rail lines tomorrow
    Shorter hours for rail lines tomorrow

    The Metro Rail Transit (MRT), Light Rail Transit (LRT) and the Philippine National Railways (PNR) will have shorter hours tomorrow for the replacement of defective railroad tracks during the Holy Week. …

  • Noy increases allowances for cops, soldiers
    Noy increases allowances for cops, soldiers

    President Aquino has signed a joint congressional resolution raising the daily subsistence allowance for both members of the Armed Forces of the Philippines (AFP) and the Philippine National Police (PNP). Presidential spokesman Edwin Lacierda said Aquino signed last March 27 the merged Joint Resolution 2 of the Senate and Joint Resolution 26 of the House of Representatives. Speaking to reporters, Lacierda yesterday said the daily allowances of police officers and soldiers were raised from P90 …

  • Oil firms raise gas prices today
    Oil firms raise gas prices today

    This year’s Holy Week break will be accompanied by an increase in local pump prices after oil companies announced yesterday a P1.10 per liter hike for gasoline and P0.60 per liter for diesel effective today. “Phoenix Petroleum Philippines will increase the prices of gasoline by P1.10 per liter and diesel by P0.60 per liter effective 6 a.m. of March 31, 2015 to reflect the movements in the prices of refined petroleum products in the international market,” said Phoenix Petroleum, an independent …

  • DFA denies dropping Phl claim to Sabah
    DFA denies dropping Phl claim to Sabah

    The Philippines has never offered to drop its Sabah claim in exchange for Malaysia’s support for Manila’s arbitration case against China over the West Philippine Sea issue, the Department of Foreign Affairs (DFA) said yesterday. “In the context of our friendly bilateral relations, our two countries have been for years exchanging ways on how to address the issue of the extended continental shelf (ECS) in the South China Sea,” Foreign Affairs spokesman Charles Jose said in explaining the DFA’s …

  • Pagcor remits record high P5 B to national treasury
    Pagcor remits record high P5 B to national treasury

    The Philippine Amusement and Gaming Corp. (Pagcor) has remitted P5 billion in cash dividends to the National Treasury, fully settling all its arrears incurred in the last several years. Pagcor chairman and chief executive officer Cristino Naguiat Jr. said with this year’s remittance, the state-owned gaming firm has fully settled all remaining arrears in cash dividends that were incurred by the previous administration since 2005. Pagcor’s cash dividends to the National Treasury under its …

  • Maysak moves closer to Phl
    Maysak moves closer to Phl

    The typhoon with international name Maysak slightly accelerated as it moved closer to the Philippines yesterday, threatening to dump rains over eastern Luzon this weekend, the state weather bureau said. Rene Paciente, senior weather forecaster of the Philippine Atmospheric, Geophysical and Astronomical Services Administration (PAGASA), said Maysak was spotted at 2,175 kilometers east of Mindanao as of 1 p.m. yesterday. Paciente said based on their latest forecast, Maysak is likely to affect …

  • Phl gets P2-B climate projects from Germany
    Phl gets P2-B climate projects from Germany

    The Philippines is getting 41 million euros or around P2 billion from the International Climate Initiative (ICI) of Germany that will fund 10 bilateral projects to address the impact of climate change. Climate Change Commission (CCC) vice chairman Lucille Sering yesterday met with Norbert Gorissen – head of the International Climate Finance of the German Federal Ministry for the Environment, Nature Conservation, Building and Nuclear Safety – to discuss the projects, some of which will be …

POLL

Should Aquino be held accountable over the Mamasapano operations?

Loading...
Poll Choice Options