OPINION: Is a currency war coming?

Hong Kong (ANN) - When Shinzo Abe became Japanese Prime Minister on Boxing Day last year, he promised to deliver change. Very shortly, he announced a 10.3 trillion yen (USD $116 billion, or 2.2% of GDP) stimulus package to end deflation and pressured the Bank of Japan to adopt a 2% inflation target. As a result, the stock market index Nikkei jumped 28.3% from mid November to current levels and the yen weakened by 20.1% from 75.7 to 90.9, its lowest level in over two years.

Such action has already provoked muttering about another currency war, invoked by Russian, German and South Korean officials.

Are we moving from a trade war to a currency war? Not yet.

Firstly, the global imbalance is already ameliorating, with the Japanese current account surplus declining sharply due to rising oil import costs.

Second, every reserve currency central bank (ECB, Fed, Bank of England and Bank of Japan) claim that they only have inflation targeting, rather than exchange rate targeting. In other words, currency rates are a consequence of the monetary policy, not a target. And we all know that if everyone devalues at the same time, there is no advantage to any single country. Since the world moved off the gold standard in 1971, everyone is aware that competitive devaluation ends up with no winners.

To be fair, the Japanese economy has been in retreat since the bubble burst in 1990. The government has tried almost every tool in the book, and their fiscal prime-pumping has pushed gross debt to over 230% of GDP, even as the population has aged very fast.

The good news is that unlike the European deficit countries, Japan is a net lender to the rest of the world to the tune of US$3.45 trillion. So, a weaker yen could reflate the economy if exports are stimulated and will also increase the yen value of Japan's net foreign exchange assets. Since Japanese exports comprise a lot of imports, especially oil and gas, it is not clear how much the tradable sector will improve. Nevertheless, tourists will flood to Japan to take advantage of high quality food and service, so the non-tradable services might revive with better employment.

The real question in terms of spillover is less in the trade account but rather in the capital account. A devaluation of the yen from around 77 to 90 is an invitation to the revival of the Yen carry trade, which was exactly what made the speculation in currency and stock market trade in the rest of Asia, financed by borrowing a devaluing Yen during the Asian financial crisis so profitable in 1997/98. So far, the markets in South East Asia are all hitting near record highs, but it is not clear how much of this is due to the carry trade or simply the broader effects of QE3 and the improvement in US stock markets.

The real questions are what is the instrument that the Bank of Japan can use to control the level of the Yen and what happens if the inflation target is really achieved, for Japan as well as the rest of the world?

Central banks have three instruments for controlling the exchange rate - the price tool, the quantitative tool and moral suasion. The market knows that the Bank of Japan cannot use the interest rate tool, because higher interest rates would hurt all borrowers, especially the huge government debt burden.

This means that guiding the exchange rate in any direction would require central bank intervention in the foreign exchange market. The Bank of Japan has intervened in the last few years to resist the Yen appreciating too much by buying dollars. So to prevent the Yen depreciating too fast, the reverse operation would have to occur. The question is how much is required to do this to keep the Yen rate stable. Intervention is credible when the leading central banks work together to intervene, as had happened in July 1998.

There are clearly several psychological barriers. The first is 100 Yen to the Dollar. As all foreign exchange traders know, once a price breaks a psychological barrier, there is likely to be an overshoot with market momentum pushing the price to another barrier, in this case 110 or 120. It took four years to move from 136 yen to the dollar in April 1991 to 85 yen in April 1995, where it stayed there for 4 months before it began to depreciate again, taking two years to depreciate to 147 in July 1998, before intervention took it again towards upward revaluation.

Between July 1998 to January 2002, the currency fluctuated between a wide range from 100 to 133, but after the Lehman failure in September 2008, the Yen was seen as a haven currency and steadily appreciated to a record level of 76 by December 2011, despite periodic intervention.


The triple trick that Abe has to pull off is not just monetary and fiscal policy, but real structural reforms. The structural problem is that the strong export sector that has kept the economy afloat in spite of an inefficient non-tradable sector is beginning to sag under the combination of strong currency and allowing competitors in the motorcar and electronics sectors to eat into Japanese market share. On top of this, the aging population is also affecting overall productivity, with population declining by 200,000 in 2011 and 2012 respectively. If growth revives with some inflation to 2%, without having to raise interest rates, the inflation eats away the debt overhang, and the trick is pulled off.

Critics of Abe's initiatives claim that it has all been tried before, with little record of success. There is little doubt that a weak Japanese economy cannot be good for both the Asian and the global economy. The coming months will be a test of nerves. If the yen goes beyond 120, then some really tough decisions will have to be made whether competitive devaluations would begin.

Watch that line.


Editor’s note:Yahoo Philippines encourages responsible comments that add dimension to the discussion. No bashing or hate speech, please. You can express your opinion without slamming others or making derogatory remarks.

  • Philippine volcano ejects ash, but no violent eruption

    MANILA, Philippines (AP) — A Philippine volcano has spewed ash but volcanologists say there are no signs of any eminent violent eruption. …

  • Pope Francis to visit Chile in 2016
    Pope Francis to visit Chile in 2016

    Pope Francis will visit Chile in 2016, the South American country confirmed, after a meeting in Rome between its foreign minister and his Vatican counterpart. The confirmation follows comments by the pope during a January visit to the Philippines, where he said he planned to travel to Chile, Argentina and Uruguay in 2016. Chilean Foreign Minister Heraldo Munoz and Vatican Secretary of State Pietro Parolin "spoke about a trip that His Holiness will make to Chile next year," the foreign …

  • Senators fail to grill DND, AFP officials on chopper deal officials on
    Senators fail to grill DND, AFP officials on chopper deal officials on

    Senators yesterday failed to grill defense and military officials over the P1.21-billion deal for the purchase of 21 Huey helicopters for the Armed Forces of the Philippines with the joint venture of Rice Aircraft Service Inc. and Eagle Copters Ltd. Francis Escudero and Joseph Victor Ejercito were interested to know why the defense department entered into a deal to buy secondhand helicopters when it is supposed to be modernizing the Armed Forces. “I am looking at the Armed Forces of the …

  • Revilla wants to undergo therapy for aching heels
    Revilla wants to undergo therapy for aching heels

    Detained Sen. Ramon Revilla Jr. has asked the Sandiganbayan to allow him to undergo therapy sessions for two weeks to treat his aching heels and back pains. In a motion filed before the anti-graft court’s First Division on Monday, Revilla’s lawyers said the senator should undergo further medical examination and treatment of his back and feet, including physical therapy at least three times a week or six sessions for two weeks, at the Philippine National Police (PNP) General Hospital at Camp …

  • Noul may intensify into typhoon – Pagasa
    Noul may intensify into typhoon – Pagasa

    Tropical Storm Noul was forecast to intensify into a typhoon before it enters the Philippine area of responsibility today, but state weather forecasters said it was unlikely to hit landmass. The Philippine Atmospheric, Geophysical and Astronomical Services Administration (PAGASA) said Noul, which will be locally named Dodong, is expected to skirt the country’s eastern coast, bringing light to moderate with occasional heavy rains over areas in Central and Northern Luzon this weekend. Rene …

  • Phl expects China to attend APEC summit in November
    Phl expects China to attend APEC summit in November

    The Philippines expects all 21 leaders of Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation member-economies, including China, to attend the summit here in November. “This is a multilateral meeting, not a bilateral meeting so there is a big difference between the two... when they come here anyway, APEC does not talk of politics, it’s all economic,” Paynor said. Yesterday at the Kalayaan grounds of Malacañang, the Asian Carmakers Corp. (ACC) held a ceremonial turnover of a fleet of BMW vehicles to be used for …

  • Senate starts probe of Chinese activities in West Phl Sea
    Senate starts probe of Chinese activities in West Phl Sea

    The Senate starts today its inquiry into the alleged reclamation and dredging activities of China in disputed territories of the West Philippine Sea (South China Sea). …

  • Noy to promote Phl in Canada
    Noy to promote Phl in Canada

    President Aquino left for the United States and Canada yesterday, bearing news of his administration’s accomplishments and hoping to attract more investments and tourists. Aquino noted the US and Canada are home to hundreds of thousands of Filipinos and have been reliable partners of the Philippines for a very long time. The two countries, he said, are participants in the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation summit in November to be hosted by the Philippines. The President is expected to arrive …


Should Aquino be held accountable over the Mamasapano operations?

Poll Choice Options