OPINION: Islands row needs peace broker

Beijing (China Daily/ANN) - In an escalated conflict that neither side wants but neither can afford to lose, resorting to negotiations is the best way to de-escalate the situation. The territorial dispute between China and Japan over the Diaoyu Islands (known in Japan as Senkaku Islands) calls for such negotiations. However, it is practically difficult for such negotiations to begin.

The Japanese central government tried to create an impression that it "nationalised" the Diaoyu Islands reluctantly. But Japan's motive is widely seen as being different and the Chinese mainland and Taiwan both have strongly opposed it.

China's reaction has been strong. To avoid being held accountable for escalating the dispute, Japan is trying in vain to remain acquiescent.

But inadvertently, it is worsening the situation by giving Japanese people the impression that the Chinese mainland and Taiwan are the ones creating trouble.

Behind the scene, there is the infamously ambivalent United States, which does not have any plan to defuse the situation.

Washington let go of an early opportunity to help defuse the tension when US Secretary of State Hillary Clinton gave just a cautionary nudge to Japan for its indecision over how to deal with Japanese right-wing forces' belligerent attitude toward China in the Diaoyu Islands issue.

For the US, intensification of the dispute between Japan and China, including a military standoff, could be mixed blessings. It would give Washington an opportunity to check out China's military might, check its rise and justify its continued, if not fortified, presence in Asia. These immediate gains to be made by the US explain why it issued a provoking message - that its security treaty with Japan covers the Diaoyu Islands - in the initial stages of the crisis.

But a full-blown conflict could also mean the failure of the US' brinkmanship. The situation could spiral out of the US' control, with the chance, even if little, of drawing Washington into direct confrontation with Beijing.

This US' ambivalence has helped extremists in Japan first wag Tokyo's tail before moving to Washington's tail. The US has wasted its leverage by failing to persuade Japan to repeal the "nationalisation" of the Diaoyu Islands in time.

The dispatching of an envoy by Japan to Beijing was at best a false promise, because envoys sent by Japan to China before a confrontation - in 1894, 1905 and 1931, for example - have not been able to solve any problem, because they have always conveyed a message of "apology": Japan's policy is irrevocable and the other side has to give in to avoid conflict.

Usually, the other side mistakes an envoy as a messenger of peace, which obviously does not apply to Japanese envoys. If this has been Japan's history, how can China accept Japan's "apology". It is even more difficult for China to accept it because it believes Japan is getting ready for a showdown.

Neither side wants a war. But neither is ready to back down from its adamant position. A compromise doesn't seem to be in the offing, because unilateral initiation by any of the two sides would be seen as surrender.

For simultaneous reconciliatory moves, however, the two sides first need to resume talks.

This too is unlikely because the situation has reached such a stage that even a hint by one of the two sides of its willingness to negotiate could be interpreted as surrender. The standoff seems to have shut off all windows of mutual benefits between China and Japan.

The US could have persuaded the two sides to open a window of negotiations. But it has lost its credibility for shamelessly seeking to cash in on the situation in the early stage of the crisis.

The only concerned party that could threaten no one else and has remained friendly connected with other sides is Taiwan. Perhaps Taiwan can shuttle between the mainland and Japan to settle the dispute as an intermediary.

Only if the two sides, especially Japan, revert to their previous stance of "shelving disputes" to deal with more pressing issues can the crisis be prevented from spiralling out of control.

The author is a professor of political science at National Taiwan University.

Loading...

Editor’s note:Yahoo Philippines encourages responsible comments that add dimension to the discussion. No bashing or hate speech, please. You can express your opinion without slamming others or making derogatory remarks.

  • Subaru XV now priced among sedans
    Subaru XV now priced among sedans

    Motor Image Philipinas (MIP), the authorized distributor of Subaru in the country, has positioned its brand new crossover SUV, the Subaru XV, well within the sedan segment’s price range. This move, according to MIP, was made to give the public an opportunity to experience the brand’s unique automotive technologies by lowering its price. Buyers of […] The post Subaru XV now priced among sedans appeared first on Carmudi Philippines. …

  • Why online business attracts SMEs?
    Why online business attracts SMEs?

    E-commerce is slowly changing the landscape of the country’s small and medium enterprises, especially in the delivery private and public transport sector. One particular area is how these firms can quickly gather or replace their fleet of vehicles with the help of online shopping made easier by online vehicle ads platform such as Carmudi Philippines—one […] The post Why online business attracts SMEs? appeared first on Carmudi Philippines. …

  • SE Asia Stocks-Mixed; Thai index slips ahead of economic data

    BANGKOK, May 22 (Reuters) - Most Southeast Asian stock markets were flat to weaker on Friday, with the Malaysia index hitting a more than two-month low and Philippines touching an over one-week low on ... …

  • China says U.S. actions in S.China Sea "irresponsible, dangerous"
    China says U.S. actions in S.China Sea "irresponsible, dangerous"

    By Sui-Lee Wee BEIJING (Reuters) - China said on Friday it was "strongly dissatisfied" after a U.S. military plane flew over part of the South China Sea near where China is building artificial islands, and called on the United States to stop such action or risk causing an accident. The Chinese navy issued eight warnings to the U.S. P8-A Poseidon, the U.S. military's most advanced surveillance aircraft, when it conducted the overflights on Wednesday, according to CNN, which had a team on board …

  • 2015 Hyundai Lateral Drift goes to Philippine Arena
    2015 Hyundai Lateral Drift goes to Philippine Arena

    The smell of burnt rubber and screeching tires are some of the highlights that will be seen at the most adrenaline-pumped drifting event of the year—the 2015 Hyundai Lateral Drift Championship series.   Held at the Philippine Arena in Bocaue, Bulacan, the event will be the biggest venue in the drifting competition. This is the […] The post 2015 Hyundai Lateral Drift goes to Philippine Arena appeared first on Carmudi Philippines. …

  • The Richest Senators In The Philippines
    The Richest Senators In The Philippines

    The 2014 Statement of Assets, Liabilities, and Net Worth for politicians and public servants are now available for anyone to … The post The Richest Senators In The Philippines appeared first on iMoney.ph. …

  • PHILIPPINES PRESS-AirAsia Philippines seeks $500 mln valuation for IPO - Inquirer

    The Philippine unit of Malaysian budget carrier AirAsia Berhad is seeking a valuation of at least $500 million for its initial public offering set within the next two years, the Philippine Daily Inquirer ... …

  • Consultant, facing joblessness, claims P5.9-M lotto pot
    Consultant, facing joblessness, claims P5.9-M lotto pot

    A 39-year-old information technology consultant, whose job contract will expire this month, has claimed his share of the 6/45 Mega Lotto’s P17.8-million jackpot in its May 13 draw, the Philippine Charity Sweepstakes Office (PCSO) announced yesterday. “I could not sleep for the past several days, thinking about where I could get the money to pay my children’s tuition,” the winner told PCSO general manager Jose Ferdinand Rojas II when he received a check for P5.9 million at the PCSO’s central …

POLL

Should Aquino be held accountable over the Mamasapano operations?

Loading...
Poll Choice Options