Plane carrying Robredo given fake safety clearance — PNoy

(Updated 4:11 p.m.) A glaring “shortcut” in obtaining a favorable flight safety rating, as well as pilot error, resulted in the August 18 plane crash that killed then-Interior and Local Government Secretary Jesse Robredo and two others, President Benigno Aquino III announced Tuesday.

Quoting results of the investigation conducted by the Aircraft Accident Inquiry and Investigation Board (AAIIB), Aquino bared that in November 2011, Aviatour, the flight school and air taxi service that operated the ill-fated Piper Seneca plane, used a fraudulent test flight clearance to prove the aircraft’s airworthiness.

He said the clearance was given by the Civil Aviation Authority of the Philippines (CAAP) even though no test flight was conducted, as evidenced by the absence of a record on the aircraft logbook.

“Nobyembre 2011 nang pinalitan ang right-hand engine propeller ng bumagsak na Piper Seneca di umano. Upang matiyak na ligtas sa paglipad ang eroplano, nag-file ng propeller overhaul report si Ginoong Nelson Napata, ang Director for Maintenance ng Aviatour’s noong Enero, na agad namang inaprubahan ng CAAP Airworthiness Inspector na si Ginoong Fernando Abalos,” Aquino said.

The January 7 test flight allegedly lasted an hour, and was given a satisfactory rating. Based on the investigation, however, no such record of the test flight ever existed.

“Walang record sa aircraft logbook ang nasabing test flight. Wala ring nakatalang flight plan dito, ayon sa Mactan International airport,” Aquino said. "Malinaw po ang ginawa nilang panlilinlang at pandaraya. Ang naging kabayaran: buhay ng tatlong tao." Aviatour

The August 18 crash that killed Robredo, his pilot Capt. Jessup Bahinting and co-pilot Kshitiz Chand, was the second for the Mactan-based Aviatour in six months, following a March crash in which two people died when its four-seater Cessna 172 crashed in Camiguin. In an exclusive report by GMA News Online last August, then-Transportation Secretary Mar Roxas said that he had ordered that Aviatour be suspended because of the March crash but aviation authorities did not comply.

Instead, CAAP only suspended Aviatour’s flying school, but the same authorities subsequently lifted it following an appeal from the Indonesian Embassy, which said many Indonesians were taking flight lessons at Aviatour’s school in Mactan. Collusion

In his report on the August 18 crash investigation, AAIIB head Capt. Amado Soliman said an Aviatour pilot confessed to falsifying a document that led to the approval of the company’s Airworthiness Certificate.

“Captain Federico A. Omolon III, Aviatour Flight Instructor and supposed pilot of the test flight testified that Captain Jessup Bahinting, Owner of Aviatour's and pilot of the fatal Seneca flight asked him to sign the Flight Test Report even though he did not fly the plane,” he said. Aquino said that based on the results of the investigation, it was clear that there was collusion between Aviatour and several CAAP inspectors.

"Base sa ilang papeles na nalikom ng investigation panel, sangkot rin ‘di umano sa kuntsabahan ang Aviatour’s at ang isang inspektor ng CAAP sa tahasang paglabag sa mga regulatory requirements," he said. "Kung tama lang ang ginawa ng ilang tao, kung sinunod lang ang mga patakaran ng industriya, kung nanatili lang na matapat sa kanilang obligasyon ang ilang sangkot, tiyak pong naiwasan dapat ang nangyaring trahedya," Aquino added. Aquino also noted that pilot error played a role in the crash. He said Bahinting, allegedly an experienced pilot, had no experience flying a one-engine inoperative emergency, nor was he familiar with the flight route to Masbate at all.

“Bagaman marami ang nagsabing ekspertong piloto si Captain Jessup M. Bahinting, wala siyang angkop na karanasan at kasanayan sa one-engine inoperative emergency. Malinaw ito nang nabigo niyang panatilihin ang ligtas na paglipad ng eroplano nang iisang makina na lamang ang gumagana,” the President said.

According to the findings of the AAIIB, Bahinting had ample time to turn back the Seneca plane the first time it encountered trouble, around 23 minutes after it left the Cebu airport. Bahinting, however, continued flying for another hour before the plane's right engine completely gave up, and another 17 minutes before the plane crashed.

“If they had turned back at the first sign of engine trouble, there is a good chance they could have landed at the Mactan-Cebu International Airport with both engines functioning,” Soliman said.

Soliman also revealed that prior to the flight, there was no pre-flight briefing conducted for the passengers, and that Bahinting’s latest license renewal did not cover “one engine inoperative emergencies,” the very problem encountered by the Seneca plane. Lesson should be learned In a statement, Robredo's wife, Leni, said the results of the investigation have brought closure to their family and they are

hoping that the incident will teach proper authorities a lesson. "Ang buong prosesong ito ang naghatid sa atin sa pagwawakas, at masakit man ang mga aral na iniwan nito, umaasa akong ang resulta ng imbestigasyon ay magbibigay-daan sa pagsagip ng maraming buhay at sa higit na kaligtasan ng lahat ng pasahero ng mga sasakyang panghimpapawid," Mrs. Robredo said in a statement. Despite the findings, Mrs. Robredo, who will seek a congressional seat in Camarines Sur province next year, said she is not about to blame anyone for her husband's tragic death.

"Makailang beses na akong tinanong kung may sinisisi ba ako sa nangyari. Ang muli ko pong tugon: Hindi ko pagtutuunan ang negatibo. Hindi ko susumbatan ang sinuman, at hindi sasama ang loob ko ukol dito," she said. — KBK/DVM/HS, GMA News


Editor’s note:Yahoo Philippines encourages responsible comments that add dimension to the discussion. No bashing or hate speech, please. You can express your opinion without slamming others or making derogatory remarks.

  • Indonesia orders execution of Mary Jane, 9 others
    Indonesia orders execution of Mary Jane, 9 others

    Indonesia has ordered preparations for the execution of 10 drug convicts, including Filipina Mary Jane Veloso, as the Philippine government filed yesterday a second appeal for judicial review of the case to save the maid from death by firing squad. The Attorney General’s Office (AGO) of Indonesia released an official letter dated April 23, instructing prosecutors to prepare for the execution of 10 convicts, the Jakarta Post reported yesterday. The execution would be conducted after the …

  • Noy to visit Canada, Japan
    Noy to visit Canada, Japan

    President Aquino will embark on a state visit to Canada in May and Japan in June to meet with his counterparts and promote Philippine interests. Deputy presidential spokesperson Abigail Valte said Aquino accepted the invitation from Canadian Governor General David Johnston to make a state visit to Canada from May 7 to 9. Tied to this trip is the President’s one-day working visit to the United States to meet with potential investors and with the local Filipino community in Chicago, Valte …

  • Business groups back K to 12 program
    Business groups back K to 12 program

    The government’s K to 12 program adding two more years to basic education received support from various business groups yesterday. However, they urged relevant government agencies to deal with issues regarding the implementation of Republic Act 10533, the Enhanced Basic Education Act or K-12 Law. In a statement, business groups led by the Philippine Business for Education (PBEd) said RA 10533 is a milestone piece of legislation that intends to bring the Philippines up to par with the rest of …

  • Happiest nations: Phl ranks 90th
    Happiest nations: Phl ranks 90th

    Switzerland is the happiest country in the world, while the Philippines placed 90th, according to a global ranking of happiness unveiled in New York on Thursday. Switzerland was followed closely by Iceland, Denmark, Norway and Canada. The 2015 World Happiness Report is the third annual report seeking to quantify happiness as a means of influencing government policy. The United Nations published the first study in 2012. …

  • Asean leaders want binding sea code with China
    Asean leaders want binding sea code with China

    Southeast Asian leaders will seek to speed up plans for a binding code of conduct with China governing behavior in the disputed South China Sea at a summit next week, Malaysia’s foreign minister said Friday. Foreign Minister Anifah Aman said a massive flow of Muslim Rohingya refugees from Myanmar to neighboring countries will also be discussed at the two-day summit of the 10-member Association of Southeast Asian Nations, which starts Monday. Anifah said leaders are expected to raise concerns …

  • S&P keeps Phl investment grade rating
    S&P keeps Phl investment grade rating

    Standard & Poor’s yesterday kept its credit rating on the Philippines on expectations the country would be able to further improve its debt metrics. The country enjoys a “BBB” rating from the debt watcher with a stable outlook. The grade, awarded to the Philippines in May last year, is a notch above the minimum investment grade (BBB-). S&P said the Philippines’ external position should remain strong with increasing foreign exchange reserves and low external debt burden. …

  • GMA takes bail plea to SC
    GMA takes bail plea to SC

    Detained former President Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo has elevated to the Supreme Court (SC) her plea to be allowed to post bail in her remaining plunder case that was rejected by the Sandiganbayan. In a 38-page petition filed last Thursday afternoon, Arroyo cited her deteriorating health in asking the high court to reverse the rulings of the Sandiganbayan’s first division in October last year and last February denying her bail motion in the case involving the P366-million Philippine Charity …

  • Mild quake hits Surigao
    Mild quake hits Surigao

    A magnitude 3.2 earthquake hit parts of Surigao del Norte yesterday, but no damage or injury was reported, the Philippine Institute of Volcanology and Seismology said. …


Should Aquino be held accountable over the Mamasapano operations?

Poll Choice Options