SC Stops Boracay Reclamation

MANILA, Philippines --- The Supreme Court (SC) has stopped indefinitely the Aklan provincial government from continuing with its P1-billion reclamation project that covers 40 hectares of coastline in Boracay Island until all legal and environmental concerns are settled with finality and fully implemented.

In a unanimous decision written by Justice Teresita J. Leonardo de Castro, the SC converted its temporary protection order (TePO) issued last year into a continuing mandamus that would place the reclamation project under its judicial scrutiny.

Placed under a cease and desist order was Phase I of the project that started in late 2010 and involves 2.64 hectares of foreshore area in Caticlan in Malay town.

The Caticlan phase, estimated to cost P260 million, would rehabilitate and expand the jetty port and passenger terminal and put up commercial building and wellness center.

Under a continuing mandamus based on the Rules of Procedure for Environmental Cases, concerned government agencies are directed "to perform an act or series of acts decreed by final judgment which shall remain effective until judgment is fully satisfied."

The SC said "the writ of continuing mandamus permits the court to retain jurisdiction after judgment in order to ensure the successful implementation of the reliefs mandated under the court's decision, and in order to do this, the court may compel the submission of compliance reports from the respondent government agencies as well as avail itself of other means to monitor compliance with its decision."

With the ruling, the SC directed the Department of Environment and Natural Resources-Environmental Management Bureau (DENR-EMB) in Region VI to review its classification of the reclamation project as a single instead of a co-located project; its approval of the provincial government's classification of

the project as a mere expansion of the existing jetty port in Caticlan, instead of classifying it as a new project; and its impact to the environment based on new, updated and comprehensive studies to be undertaken by the DENR-EMB Region VI.

The SC also ordered the provincial government of Aklan to conduct proper consultations with non-governmental organizations and other stakeholders and sectors concerned and to secure the necessary clearances from local government units to be affected by the reclamation project, and to cooperate with the DENR-EMB in its review of the reclamation project.

On the other hand, the Philippine Reclamation Authority (PRA) was directed to monitor closely the submission by the Aklan provincial government of the requirements to be issued by the DENR-EMB in connection to the environmental concerns raised by petitioner Boracay Foundation, Inc. (BFI).

Three months from the promulgation of the decision on June 26, 2012, the BFI, the PRA, the DENR-EMB, and the Aklan provincial government were ordered by the SC to submit their respective reports on their compliance with its requirements.

The TePO against the reclamation project was issued by the SC on June 7, 2011 as it granted the plea of BFI, a group of resort, hotel, and restaurant operators in Boracay, as well as community organizations and environmental advocates.

In seeking a stop to the project, BFI - through lawyer Joel Ruiz Butuyan - said that a comprehensive impact assessment and public hearings should first be conducted.

It pointed out that any reclamation project involving so-called "co-located" projects are subject to "programmatic" impact assessments studies, which the provincial government failed to perform.

"The various unlawful machinations perpetrated by respondent province in fraudulently classifying and misrepresenting as a non-environmentally critical project in an ECA (environmental critical areas), the subject project, and as a single project instead of a co-located one, has unlawfully and improperly provided it with opportunity to exploit and circumvent the regulations intended to protect the environment, particularly those environmental critical areas particularly Boracay," it said.

Citing provincial government documents, BFI said that the Phase I of the project is located on the Caticlan side, which is known to be a mere "rehabilitation" of the existing jetty port, the gateway from mainland Aklan to Boracay, which is separated only by a narrow strait of water.

It said that Phase 2 of the project covers 3.18 hectares on Boracay.

According to BFI, "it is impossible for respondent DENR-EMB not to be aware of the fragile ecological balance which creates the condition for Boracay's white-sand beaches."

It stressed that there is no necessity for a reclamation project in the area and that, based on a study conducted by University of the Philippines marine biologists, the reclamation project will likely affect the current and flow of the tides in the area, and may cause further erosion of the sands in Boracay.


Editor’s note:Yahoo Philippines encourages responsible comments that add dimension to the discussion. No bashing or hate speech, please. You can express your opinion without slamming others or making derogatory remarks.

  • Philippine military chief confirms wanted militant killed

    MANILA, Philippines (AP) — The Philippine military chief confirmed Monday that wanted Filipino bomb-maker Basit Usman, who has links to the Indonesian-based Jemaah Islamiyah terrorist network and is a suspect in deadly bomb attacks in the south, has been killed. …

  • PSC sports venues deteriorating – COA
    PSC sports venues deteriorating – COA

    The Commission on Audit (COA) has noted the sorry state of the country’s sports venues despite supposedly receiving sufficient funds from the government. It reported that the Philippine Sports Commission (PSC) got an additional budget of P626.563 million in 2013 alone but failed to maintain and upgrade the Rizal Memorial Sports Complex (RMSC) in Malate, Manila and the Philsports Complex in Pasig City. This, according to the COA report, is already a disadvantage to the country’s athletes. …

  • Taguig bettor wins P39.2-M lotto jackpot
    Taguig bettor wins P39.2-M lotto jackpot

    A player from Taguig City won the jackpot of the 6/42 Regular Lotto’s May 2 draw, the Philippine Charity Sweepstakes Office (PCSO) announced yesterday. PCSO general manager Jose Ferdinand Rojas said the still unidentified winner guessed the six-digit winning combination, 12-42-16-04-11-08, which has a jackpot of P39.2 million. At least 80 other players won P11,420 each after they guessed five digits of the winning combination. The 6/42 Regular Lotto online game is drawn every Tuesday, …

  • Tropical depression spotted off Mindanao
    Tropical depression spotted off Mindanao

    A tropical depression hovering over the Pacific Ocean is expected to enter the Philippine area of responsibility on Thursday and may bring much-needed rain to the country later this week, the state weather bureau said yesterday. As of 10 a.m. yesterday, the weather disturbance was spotted at 1,615 kilometers east of Mindanao with maximum winds of 45 kilometers per hour near the center, the Philippine Atmospheric, Geophysical and Astronomical Services Administration (PAGASA) said. PAGASA said …

  • Phl to seek Mary Jane’s return
    Phl to seek Mary Jane’s return

    The Philippine government is exploring options to extend the temporary reprieve granted by Indonesia to Filipina death row convict Mary Jane Veloso, Justice Secretary Leila de Lima said yesterday. De Lima said they would look into the possibility of asking the Indonesian government to allow Veloso to return home to testify in the human trafficking, illegal recruitment and swindling cases filed by the Department of Justice (DOJ) against her alleged illegal recruiters Ma. …

  • Mayweather picks off Pacquiao to join greats
    Mayweather picks off Pacquiao to join greats

    Floyd Mayweather's emphatic win over Manny Pacquiao sealed his status as a boxing great, but triggered an outcry in the Philippines and divided opinion amongst the sports legends. Feinting and dancing his way to a unanimous decision, Mayweather comfortably picked off Pacquiao over 12 rounds to extend his 19-year unbeaten record to 48-0. Yet the jeers could not obscure a clear win for the skilful Mayweather, with judges awarding him the decision by margins of 118-110 and 116-112. Mayweather, …

  • Sadness, disappointment in Philippines after Pacquiao defeat
    Sadness, disappointment in Philippines after Pacquiao defeat

    MANILA, Philippines (AP) — Sadness and disappointment gripped Filipinos after Manny Pacquiao's defeat in his much-anticipated fight against American Floyd Mayweather Jr. but they still considered the boxing icon a national hero. …

  • Philippine rebels kill most wanted Islamist militant in south

    The Philippines' most wanted Islamist militant, who escaped after a raid in January that killed 44 police commandos, was killed on Sunday in firefight with Muslim rebels, officials said. Protracted police operations to arrest three Islamist high-value targets had become the biggest political crisis in five years for President Benigno Aquino and put at risk his government's peace efforts with Moro Islamic Liberation Front. A proposed law creating a new autonomous government for minority …


Should Aquino be held accountable over the Mamasapano operations?

Poll Choice Options