Horizon Towers. (Photo via PropertyGuru)By Pooja Thakur
Barely a week into 2019 and Singapore’s residential home sales market is facing a S$1.1 billion ($811 million) litmus test. Horizon Towers, an older-style building near the popular Orchard Road shopping district, has gone on the market for redevelopment a third time after two failed attempts.
The sellers’ collective has retained its reserve price but other groups of homeowners also seeking so-called en-bloc deals are cutting their asking bids in the hope developers will bite.
En-bloc sales announced in 2019
- HighPoint (Reserve price: S$550 million)
Launched for sale, tender closes Feb. 26
- Tanah Merah Mansion (Reserve price: S$80 million)
First tender, expected to launch next week
- Flynn Park (Reserve price: S$325 million)
Relaunched, about 75% of the owners have agreed to lower the reserve price from S$363.8 million
- Horizon Towers (Reserve price: S$1.1 billion)
Relaunched, similar price
- Cavenagh Gardens (Reserve price: S$480 million)
Relaunched, similar price
- Choon Kim House (Reserve price: S$50 million)
Relaunched, lowered from S$55 million
Source: JLL, CBRE, Cushman & Wakefield
For individuals who have held apartments for several years and ridden the property boom, the profits can be handsome. En-bloc, or collective, sales are where a group of apartments are sold to a common developer and the proceeds divided among unit owners. (In general, if a development is more than 10 years old, at least 80 percent of owners must agree to a sale.)
But government cooling measures introduced in July that increased the stamp duties home builders need to pay when acquiring land have made market watchers skeptical about how many transactions will be a success.
“Billion-dollar en-bloc deals will be very hard to get through,” said Nicholas Mak, an executive director at real estate asset manager ZACD Group. “Developers are no longer land hungry and are more concerned about selling existing projects.”
Singapore imposed higher stamp duties and tougher loan-to-value rules in early July after residential prices in the city-state rose 7 percent in the first half of 2018. Extra constraints since then have included curbs on the number of “shoe-box-sized” apartments, limiting transactions at the cheaper end of the market.
That’s a particular blow for en-bloc deals because developers often acquire older buildings with larger units and then redo the floor sizes to accommodate more dwellings. The new guidelines on size, outlined in October, effectively cut the maximum number of apartments allowed in any one development by 18 percent. The changes only affect projects outside the city-state’s central area, and come into effect later this month.
“With expectations of a slowdown in sales in 2019, developers might re-think their land banking strategy, or even stop looking altogether,” said Derek Tan, an analyst at DBS Group Holdings Ltd. “As the government moves in with more restrictive measures to curb both demand and supply, we expect developers to focus on clearing inventories rather than adding more.”
The Southeast Asian lender expects new home sales to drop 20 percent this year to between 7,500 and 8,500 units, and prices to slip as much as 3 percent.
Horizon Towers was relaunched for sale after an unsuccessful attempt last year. The 99-year leasehold estate, which was completed in 1984, comprises about 210 units and was most recently renovated in 2014. The first attempt for an en-bloc sale was made a decade ago at S$500 million, but the transaction fell through after a court ruled the sales process was improperly handled.
Park View Mansions is another relaunch, but at a reserve price that’s 22 percent lower. Gilstead Mansion, a condominium near Singapore’s Little India district, reduced its price guide by S$3 million to S$65 million and still couldn’t find a taker.
“Although some sites have slashed their reserve prices, developers have turned cautious and many won’t be in a hurry to bid for land unless an attractive deal comes to market,” Christine Li, head of research for Singapore at Cushman & Wakefield Inc., said.
En-bloc sale tenders announced in 2018 and closing this year
- 409-419 Upper East Coast Rd (Asking price: S$18 million)
- Beauty World Plaza (Reserve price: S$165 million)
- Golden Mile Complex (Reserve price: S$800 million)
- Park View Mansions (Reserve price: S$250 million)
(Relaunched, lowered asking price from S$320m to S$250m)
- Phoenix Road Apartments (Asking price: S$42 million)
- Elias Green (Reserve price: S$780 million)
Developers spent around S$30 billion between late 2016 and June last year acquiring land through government tenders or redevelopment deals, one of the most-active periods since 2013, DBS said. They’ll need to shell out significantly more after the hike in stamp duties, increasing business risk.
“The en-bloc outlook remains challenging,” Li said. “There’s a mismatch in expectations between developers and sellers — asking prices are still relatively high and developers are wary about paying top dollar.”
© 2019 Bloomberg L.P