US Case Poses Threat To 2013 Polls

MANILA, Philippines --- A legal controversy in the United States between Smartmatic International Corporation and the US-based owner of the optical scan voting system technology is putting the integrity of the May 2013 elections in jeopardy.

Militant lawmakers led by Bayan Muna Rep. Neri Javier Colmenares aired this concern as they revealed that the court suit between Smartmatic and Dominion Voting Systems International Corporation could prevent the former from complying with its contractual obligations with the Commission on Elections (Comelec) which has decided to purchase the Smartmatic Precinct Count Optical Scan (PCOS) machines for use in next year's polls.

Colmenares, together with Reps. Luzviminda Ilagan (Gabriela) and Antonio Tinio (Act Teachers party-list), filed House Resolution No. 2849 calling for a congressional inquiry into the alleged "misrepresentation and fraud" of Smartmatic when it entered into a contract with Comelec.

However, Comelec Chairman Sixto Brillantes described the calling of a congressional inquiry as premature. "I think they should listen to us first before they call for an inquiry. They should listen first to us," Brillantes said in an interview.

Colmenares said the investigation will also help Congress determine legislative actions that may be put in place to avert possible adverse impacts of the Court of Chancery of the State of Delaware case to the 2013 elections.

"The interest of the Filipino people in the legal controversy between Smartmatic and Dominion arises from the possibility that Smartmatic may have been liable for misrepresentation or fraud when it entered into a Deed of Sale with the Commission on Elections, to the prejudice of the Filipino people and the jeopardy of the upcoming automated polls next year," Colmenares said.

The administration lawmaker said the legislative inquiry will determine whether or not Comelec possessed all the information regarding the PCOS technology.

It will also look into Smartmatic's capacity to fulfil its obligations and promises at the time when the option to purchase was exercised and during the execution of the Deed of Sale.

According to the authors of HR 2849, Smartmatic sued Dominion on Sept. 11, 2012 before the Delaware court. The complaint stemmed from the PCOS Framework License Agreement executed between the two firms.

Under the business agreement, Dominion, which owns the optical scan voting system technology, granted to Smartmatic the license to exploit the said technology, including its marketing to other countries outside the United States.

Smartmatic claimed Dominion failed to honor its commitments and has interfered with its business of developing and providing for the automated election systems in Mongolia, Puerto Rico, and the Philippines.

"This would only mean that Smartmatic could not possibly comply with the conditions set forth by Comelec in the Deed of Sale until and unless the State of Delaware rules in its favor and rule immediately," Colmenares said.

Lawmakers said the Smartmatic complaint shows that the ownership of and full control of the PCOS technology is deeply embroiled in legal dispute. He added the court case also indicates that Smartmatic has no full control over the same, so as to enable it to make the changes necessary for the technology to be fully compliant with Republic Act 9369 and other Philippine Laws.

On July 2012, the Supreme Court upheld the validity and constitutionality of the purchase by the Comelec of the PCOS machines and other goods despite the palpable infirmities and defects of the PCOS machines.

"However, said SC decision was rendered without reference and information as to the legal controversy between Smartmatic and Dominion. The Highest Court upheld the Comelec's exercise of the option to purchase the goods but on the assumption that despite palpable infirmities and defects in the goods, Smartmatic can provide the enhancements required and requested by Comelec and Philippines laws," Colmenares said.

As the complaint would reveal, Smartmatic has no such capacity at the time of the execution of the Deed of Sale and even until present, seven months before the 2013 elections, they added.

Furthermore, HR 2849 states that "following the allegations in the complaint, the continuing refusal of Dominion to recognize the License Agreement obligating Dominion to provide the enhancements, improvements and modifications needed and requested by the Comelec, is detrimental to the Philippine elections, as well as renders the contract between the Comelec and Smartmatic defective." (With a report from Leslie Aquino)


Editor’s note:Yahoo Philippines encourages responsible comments that add dimension to the discussion. No bashing or hate speech, please. You can express your opinion without slamming others or making derogatory remarks.

  • Lupita Nyong'o's $150,000 Oscars dress stolen from hotel
    Lupita Nyong'o's $150,000 Oscars dress stolen from hotel

    The $150,000 pearl-studded, custom-made Calvin Klein dress worn by Oscar-winning actress Lupita Nyong'o at this year's Academy Awards has been stolen, police said on Thursday. The gown, embellished with 6,000 natural white pearls, was stolen from Nyong'o's room at the London Hotel in West Hollywood, during the day on Wednesday, a spokesman for the Los Angeles County Sheriff's Department in West Hollywood said. "Ms Nyong'o was not in the room at the time of the theft," Deputy John Mitchell …

  • South Korea decriminalises adultery, condom shares soar
    South Korea decriminalises adultery, condom shares soar

    South Korea's Constitutional Court on Thursday struck down a controversial adultery law which for more than 60 years had criminalised extra-marital sex and jailed violators for up to two years. The decision saw shares in the South Korean firm Unidus Corp., one of the world's largest condom manufacturers, soar by the daily limit of 15 percent on the local stock exchange. "Even if adultery should be condemned as immoral, state power should not intervene in individuals' private lives," said …

  • US-led strikes on IS after group seizes 220 Christians
    US-led strikes on IS after group seizes 220 Christians

    The US-led coalition has carried out air strikes against the Islamic State group in northeastern Syria, where the jihadists have launched a new offensive and kidnapped 220 Assyrian Christians. The raids on Thursday struck areas around the town of Tal Tamr in Hasakeh province, the Syrian Observatory for Human Rights said, without giving information on possible casualties. The town remains under the control of Kurdish forces, but at least 10 surrounding villages have been seized by IS, along …

  • U.S. flies most advanced surveillance plane from Philippines

    By Manuel Mogato MANILA (Reuters) - The United States has begun flying its most advanced surveillance aircraft, the P-8A Poseidon, out of the Philippines for patrols over the South China Sea, the U.S. Navy said on Thursday, acknowledging the flights for the first time. The United States, the Philippines' oldest and closest ally, has promised to share "real time" information on what is happening in Philippine waters as China steps up its activities in the South China Sea. China claims most of …

  • Militants abduct more Christians, smash ancient artifacts
    Militants abduct more Christians, smash ancient artifacts

    BEIRUT (AP) — Islamic State militants seized more Christians from their homes in northeastern Syria in the past three days, bringing the total number abducted by the extremist group to over 220, activists said Thursday. …

  • Purisima denies endorsing successor
    Purisima denies endorsing successor

    Resigned Philippine National Police (PNP) chief Director General Alan Purisima denied reports that he has been urging President Aquino to appoint his protegé as the new police chief. “Contrary to news reports, PDG Alan La Madrid Purisima is not in any position to recommend and has not in fact recommended anyone to the President for appointment as next chief of the PNP,” his lawyer Kristoffer James Purisima said yesterday. Sources said that Purisima may have resigned but he reportedly remains …

  • IS executioner 'Jihadi John' named as London graduate
    IS executioner 'Jihadi John' named as London graduate

    "Jihadi John", the masked Islamic State group militant believed responsible for beheading of at least five Western hostages, has been named as Kuwaiti-born computing graduate Mohammed Emwazi from London. "Jihadi John", nicknamed after Beatle John Lennon due to his British accent, is believed to be responsible for the murders of US journalists James Foley and Steven Sotloff, British aid workers David Haines and Alan Henning and American aid worker Abdul-Rahman Kassig. …

  • ‘Noy angered by previous SAF failures to get Marwan’
    ‘Noy angered by previous SAF failures to get Marwan’

    Supt. Raymund Train, who led the SAF team that killed Marwan in Mamasapano, Maguindanao on Jan. 25, recounted in a sworn statement the meeting he and senior SAF officers had with Aquino in Malacañang on Nov. 30. Train said among the senior officers who attended the meeting were then PNP chief Director General Alan Purisima, SAF chief Director Getulio Napeñas, SAF deputy commander Chief Supt. Noli Taliño and intelligence group chief Senior Supt. Fernando Mendez. …


Should Aquino be held accountable over the Mamasapano operations?

Poll Choice Options