US Case Poses Threat To 2013 Polls

MANILA, Philippines --- A legal controversy in the United States between Smartmatic International Corporation and the US-based owner of the optical scan voting system technology is putting the integrity of the May 2013 elections in jeopardy.

Militant lawmakers led by Bayan Muna Rep. Neri Javier Colmenares aired this concern as they revealed that the court suit between Smartmatic and Dominion Voting Systems International Corporation could prevent the former from complying with its contractual obligations with the Commission on Elections (Comelec) which has decided to purchase the Smartmatic Precinct Count Optical Scan (PCOS) machines for use in next year's polls.

Colmenares, together with Reps. Luzviminda Ilagan (Gabriela) and Antonio Tinio (Act Teachers party-list), filed House Resolution No. 2849 calling for a congressional inquiry into the alleged "misrepresentation and fraud" of Smartmatic when it entered into a contract with Comelec.

However, Comelec Chairman Sixto Brillantes described the calling of a congressional inquiry as premature. "I think they should listen to us first before they call for an inquiry. They should listen first to us," Brillantes said in an interview.

Colmenares said the investigation will also help Congress determine legislative actions that may be put in place to avert possible adverse impacts of the Court of Chancery of the State of Delaware case to the 2013 elections.

"The interest of the Filipino people in the legal controversy between Smartmatic and Dominion arises from the possibility that Smartmatic may have been liable for misrepresentation or fraud when it entered into a Deed of Sale with the Commission on Elections, to the prejudice of the Filipino people and the jeopardy of the upcoming automated polls next year," Colmenares said.

The administration lawmaker said the legislative inquiry will determine whether or not Comelec possessed all the information regarding the PCOS technology.

It will also look into Smartmatic's capacity to fulfil its obligations and promises at the time when the option to purchase was exercised and during the execution of the Deed of Sale.

According to the authors of HR 2849, Smartmatic sued Dominion on Sept. 11, 2012 before the Delaware court. The complaint stemmed from the PCOS Framework License Agreement executed between the two firms.

Under the business agreement, Dominion, which owns the optical scan voting system technology, granted to Smartmatic the license to exploit the said technology, including its marketing to other countries outside the United States.

Smartmatic claimed Dominion failed to honor its commitments and has interfered with its business of developing and providing for the automated election systems in Mongolia, Puerto Rico, and the Philippines.

"This would only mean that Smartmatic could not possibly comply with the conditions set forth by Comelec in the Deed of Sale until and unless the State of Delaware rules in its favor and rule immediately," Colmenares said.

Lawmakers said the Smartmatic complaint shows that the ownership of and full control of the PCOS technology is deeply embroiled in legal dispute. He added the court case also indicates that Smartmatic has no full control over the same, so as to enable it to make the changes necessary for the technology to be fully compliant with Republic Act 9369 and other Philippine Laws.

On July 2012, the Supreme Court upheld the validity and constitutionality of the purchase by the Comelec of the PCOS machines and other goods despite the palpable infirmities and defects of the PCOS machines.

"However, said SC decision was rendered without reference and information as to the legal controversy between Smartmatic and Dominion. The Highest Court upheld the Comelec's exercise of the option to purchase the goods but on the assumption that despite palpable infirmities and defects in the goods, Smartmatic can provide the enhancements required and requested by Comelec and Philippines laws," Colmenares said.

As the complaint would reveal, Smartmatic has no such capacity at the time of the execution of the Deed of Sale and even until present, seven months before the 2013 elections, they added.

Furthermore, HR 2849 states that "following the allegations in the complaint, the continuing refusal of Dominion to recognize the License Agreement obligating Dominion to provide the enhancements, improvements and modifications needed and requested by the Comelec, is detrimental to the Philippine elections, as well as renders the contract between the Comelec and Smartmatic defective." (With a report from Leslie Aquino)

Loading...

Editor’s note:Yahoo Philippines encourages responsible comments that add dimension to the discussion. No bashing or hate speech, please. You can express your opinion without slamming others or making derogatory remarks.

  • Aquino: Philippines to fly usual routes over disputed reefs

    MANILA, Philippines (AP) — Philippine aircraft will continue to fly their usual routes over disputed reefs in the South China Sea, the country's president said Monday, defying China's challenges to its planes and those of the United States. …

  • Philippines to fly over disputed South China Sea: Aquino
    Philippines to fly over disputed South China Sea: Aquino

    Philippine military and commercial aircraft will keep flying over disputed areas in the South China Sea despite Chinese warnings over the airspace, President Benigno Aquino said on Monday. "We will still fly the routes that we fly based on the international law from the various conventions we entered into," Aquino told reporters when asked whether the Philippines accepted China's position. The Chinese military last week ordered a US Navy P-8 Poseidon surveillance plane away from airspace …

  • Mitsubishi reaches out to far-flung Batad community
    Mitsubishi reaches out to far-flung Batad community

    A “Dadbod” is a newly coined term now trending in media. It was introduced to the world by Clemson University sophomore Mackenzie Pearson as she refers to any man—father or bachelor—with a physique that’s a “nice balance between a beer gut and working out.” “It’s more human, natural, and attractive,” she adds. For this writer, […] The post Mitsubishi reaches out to far-flung Batad community appeared first on Carmudi Philippines. …

  • A weekend of premium cars
    A weekend of premium cars

    Good news to all luxury car fanatics as PGA Cars, the exclusive importer and distributor of Audi, Porsche, Lamborghini and Bentley cars in the country, will be holding the PGA Cars Premium Festival from May 29 to May 31 at the PGA Center in Global City in Taguig. The 3-day event will showcase PGA’s latest […] The post A weekend of premium cars appeared first on Carmudi Philippines. …

  • APEC ministers to endorse Boracay Action Agenda
    APEC ministers to endorse Boracay Action Agenda

    Trade ministers at the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) meeting in Boracay, Aklan agreed yesterday to endorse the proposed Boracay Action Agenda to the member countries’ leaders, presenting opportunities for global trade for micro, small and medium enterprises (MSMEs). In a press conference following the conclusion of the APEC Ministers Responsible for Trade Meeting, Trade Secretary Gregory Domingo, who also served as chairman, said ministers agreed to recommend the adoption of the …

  • Talks with China over sea row urged
    Talks with China over sea row urged

    The Philippines should engage China in bilateral talks in its efforts to maintain peace and order at the disputed West Philippine Sea, Sen. Francis Escudero said yesterday. Escudero supports the government’s move to bring the issue before international arbitration but also stressed the need for the Philippines to pursue talks with China. Escudero made the statement after UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon on Friday called for a peaceful solution to territorial disputes in the South China Sea. …

  • House panel tackles bill on regular disaster drills
    House panel tackles bill on regular disaster drills

    The House committee on national defense is deliberating on a measure mandating the regular conduct of disaster risk reduction drills in educational institutions nationwide. Authored by Camarines Sur Rep. Rolando Andaya Jr., the bill mandates that risk reduction drills be held annually in all educational institutions throughout the country in coordination with the schools’ respective local government units. “The Philippines’ location along the Pacific Ring of Fire and close to the equator …

  • PCSO running out of funds
    PCSO running out of funds

    Philippine Charity Sweepstakes Office (PCSO) chairman Ireneo Maliksi has admitted that the revenue-generating agency is running out of funds as it continues with its mandate to provide financial assistance to indigent Filipinos. Aside from providing financial help to individual recipients, Maliksi cited at least 13 laws that mandates the PCSO to provide mandatory contribution to different government agencies. Just last week, PCSO released P100 million to the Commission on Higher Education as …

POLL

Should Aquino be held accountable over the Mamasapano operations?

Loading...
Poll Choice Options