US Supreme Court reviews Arizona immigration law

The US Supreme Court appeared to lean Wednesday in favor of upholding a controversial Arizona immigration law, brushing back arguments that the southwestern state's crackdown on illegal immigrants encroaches on federal powers.

More than 1,000 protesters outside the court lashed out against provisions of the law that they say encourages ethnic profiling as the justices heard arguments for and against the 2010 law, known as SB1070.

It was the second time this session that the top US court has waded into a hot-button election year issue, after holding three days of hearings last month on President Barack Obama's landmark health care reform laws.

The Arizona law has aroused intense controversy because of provisions that require police to stop and demand proof of citizenship of anyone they suspect of being illegal, even without probable cause.

But Chief Justice John Roberts immediately put Solicitor General Donald Verrilli on the spot by pointing out that the federal government's arguments could not center on the civil rights issues, but rather on its claim under the constitution to exclusive authority in immigration matters.

"No part of your argument has to do with racial or ethnic profiling?" Roberts asked.

Verrilli agreed, saying: "The Constitution vests exclusive authority over immigration matters with the national government."

Roberts however went on to suggest that the law's most controversial provisions were not an effort to override federal law, but to support it.

Justice Anthony Kennedy, often the swing vote on the court, said Arizona was "cooperating in implementing federal law."

The court's conservative majority has been strengthened in this case because Justice Elena Kagan, who served as solicitor general under Obama, recused herself, leaving only eight justices to hear the matter.

But even the three more liberal justices showed little enthusiasm for the government's position, although Justice Stephen Breyer expressed concern that the Arizona law would lead to longer detentions of significant numbers of people.

Paul Clement, who argued Arizona's case, hammered away at the position that the state's law was compatible with federal law, insisting "there is no interference with federal authority."

Outside the court, more than 1,000 opponents of the law gathered to denounce it as a violation of civil rights and a vehicle for discrimination against Hispanics.

"God, give us the courage to stand up against Draconian immigration laws," Reverend Gabriel Salguero, president of the National Latino Evangelical Coalition, said in a prayer.

But conservative backers of the law emerged from the hour-long oral arguments optimistic that their side would prevail in June, when the court is expected to hand down its decision in the thick of the election campaign.

"I was very gratified. I thought they had a handle (on the issues) and I thought it was a clear victory," Russell Pearce, the Arizona state senator who wrote the law, told reporters.

Last year, lower courts opted to strike sections of the law they said would place a burden on legal resident aliens in Arizona, where a third of the 6.6 million people are foreign-born and more than 400,000 are illegal immigrants.

But Arizona appealed, claiming that "the federal government has largely ignored Arizona's pleas for additional resources and help" in stemming the tide of illegal immigration into the state, which borders Mexico.

Arizona governor Jan Brewer -- who earlier this year was caught on camera pointing her finger in Obama's face in what looked to be a testy exchange on an airport tarmac -- has asked the top court to reinstate the suspended sections.

Beyond the identity checks without probable cause, the other sections in question would make it a crime to be in the United States unlawfully and require non-citizens to carry their identity papers with them at all times.

Also at issue is a provision that would make it a crime for illegal migrants to seek work, and one authorizing law enforcement officials to stop anyone they believe may have committed a crime that would result in their expulsion.

If there is a four-four tie, the lower court's decision to strike the provisions will be upheld.

"This case has huge implications for law enforcement and for civil rights. If the Supreme Court decides the wrong way, it's going to be a battle all over the country, state after state," said Anthony Romero, director of the American Civil Liberties Union.

Mexico and 17 other countries have also filed arguments with the Supreme Court opposing the law, saying the delegation of authority over such matters to individual states threatens bilateral relations with Washington.

Verrilli pointed out that the case could have significant consequences for Washington's relations with other countries, to which Justice Antonin Scalia replied: "We have to enforce our laws in the manner that pleases Mexico?"

At least 36 states have introduced legislation with elements similar to those in Arizona, five of which have been passed.


Editor’s note:Yahoo Philippines encourages responsible comments that add dimension to the discussion. No bashing or hate speech, please. You can express your opinion without slamming others or making derogatory remarks.

  • Phl, US defense chiefs to meet on sea dispute
    Phl, US defense chiefs to meet on sea dispute

    As US aircraft carrier USS Ronald Regan began its journey to Asian waters amid China’s power flexing in the region, Defense Secretary Voltaire Gazmin would try to hear directly from his US counterpart how far America is willing to go to aid its long-time ally against China’s threatening moves in disputed waters. Gazmin flew to Hawaii last Monday to attend ceremonies for the turnover of leadership of the United States Pacific Command (USPACOM) from Admiral Samuel Locklear to Admiral Harry …

  • Water in Angat Dam falls below critical level
    Water in Angat Dam falls below critical level

    The water level of Angat Dam in Bulacan yesterday fell below the 180-meter critical level for irrigation, the Philippine Atmospheric, Geophysical and Astronomical Services Administration (PAGASA) said. PAGASA said the dam’s water level further dropped to 179.98 meters as of 6 a.m. yesterday from 180.2 meters on Monday. The priority is the domestic consumption in Metro Manila, according to PAGASA. …

  • PCSO gets P3-B fund for medical aid
    PCSO gets P3-B fund for medical aid

    The Philippine Charity Sweepstakes Office (PCSO) reported yesterday that an estimated P3-billion charity fund has been allocated by Congress to the agency to provide medical assistance to indigent patients and also give funds to other government offices including the Philippine Drug Enforcement Agency (PDEA) and the Crop Insurance Program. …

  • Image of Asia: Tearing down squatters' homes near Manila
    Image of Asia: Tearing down squatters' homes near Manila

    In this photo by Bullit Marquez, a demolition crew begins to tear down a squatters' community at suburban Caloocan city, north of Manila, Philippines. Population growth and the lack of economic opportunities in rural areas have driven millions of Filipinos into the squatters' colonies that dot the sprawling metropolitan area in and around Manila. Most of the land they occupy is privately owned, and clearing the dwellings often results in violence. The landowner had offered about $1,344 in …

  • SE Asia Stocks - Mostly down; Thai shares near 2-week low

    BANGKOK, May 26 (Reuters) - Most sharemarkets in Southeast Asia fell on Tuesday with the Thai index ending at a near two-week low and the Philippines touching a near four-week low after trade data while ... …

  • China breaks ground on lighthouse project in South China Sea

    China hosted a groundbreaking ceremony for the building of two lighthouses in the disputed South China Sea, state media said on Tuesday, a move that is likely to escalate tensions in a region already jittery about Beijing's maritime ambitions. China's Ministry of Transport hosted the ceremony for the construction of two multi-functional lighthouses on Huayang Reef and Chigua Reef on the disputed Spratly islands, state news agency Xinhua said, defying calls from the United States and the …

  • SE Asia Stocks - Thai, Philippine indexes weak after trade data

    BANGKOK, May 26 (Reuters) - Most Southeast Asian stock markets rose in line with the rest of Asia on Tuesday but the Thai index pared early gains after weak trade data in April, while the Philippine benchmark ... …

  • Is your home on top of a faultline?
    Is your home on top of a faultline?

    The Philippine Institute of Volcanoly and Seismology (PHIVOLCS) recently issued an updated and high-resolution "atlas" of the East Valley Fault and West Valley Fault, two major faultlines that run through sections of Metro Manila. Metro Manila may be due for a 7.2-magnitude earthquake within this lifetime, say experts from the institute, among them PHIVOLCS director Dr. Renato Solidum, Jr. According to records, the last major earthquake caused by the West Valley Fault took place 357 years …


Should Aquino be held accountable over the Mamasapano operations?

Poll Choice Options